Ann Pettway Admits Stealing Baby, Raising Girl as Her Own

A woman who snatched an infant from a New York City hospital 24 years ago and raised her as her daughter will plead guilty today of a federal kidnapping charge and faces at least 20 years in prison.

Ann Pettway took Carlina White when she was 19 days old from Harlem Hospital in Manhattan.

"Ms. Pettway will be entering a guilty plea tomorrow to charges set forth in a new information to be filed tomorrow," her lawyer Robert Baum said in a statement Thursday

Pettway, 50, could be sentenced to life in prison, but the charges carries a mandatory minimum of 20 years.

White, who had been brought to the hospital with a fever by her concerned parents,was hooked up to an IV. Pettway posed a nurse, took the baby from the couple and pretended to take her for treatment.

Joy White and Carl Tyson spent the next 23 years wondering what had happened to their daughter.

"Pettway was dealing with the stress of trying to be a mom and had had several miscarriages. She did not believe she would ever be able to be a parent," a court document filed by FBI Special Agent Maria Johnson who interviewed Pettway, stated. Johnson is a member of the FBI's Crimes Against Children Squad.

Pettway boarded a train for her home in Bridgeport, Conn., and told friends and family member the baby was her child.

For the following 23 years, Carlina White became Nejdra Nance.

But the lack of a birth certificate, Social Security card, or the missing resemblance to Pettway led White to question her identity when she was in her late teens.

White ultimately discovered that she had been kidnapped as a baby by searching missing children web sites, and in early 2011, was finally reunited with her real family.

Pettway went on the run after the kidnapping and reunion of White with her biological family made headlines, police said.

Authorities issued a warrant for Pettway's arrest for violating her parole in a North Carolina embezzlement case. A family member worked with authorities to arrange Pettway's surrender.

She "looked like the world was lifted off her shoulders ... looked a bit relieved ... because she had been running," Lt. David Daniels of the Bridgeport Police Department said.

Carlina White described Pettway to the New York Post last year as an abusive mother who would throw things like shoes at her. Pettway later moved to Atlanta, taking Carlina with her.

Meanwhile, the family that long hoped for their daughter's return is making up for lost time.

White's parents sued the city and with the money they won established a trust fund for their daughter in the event of her return.

Also Read
 
  • Crazyman762  •  Woodbury, New Jersey  •  3 months ago
    How did a person get to be 23 without a birth certificate or Social Security number? Did she go to school? Even under the circumstances someone - some school official should have pressed for proper I D.
    • Kuuipo 3 months ago
      I don't think my children needed to show a Social Security card, just the number and is that really used? And they never needed to show their birth certificates, either.
    • Bud 3 months ago
      In modern times you are automatically issued a social security number. Now before 1986 you did not get a social security card until you were about 14 which is when many States allowed minors to obtain "working papers".

      And as for pressing for proper ID at schools, don't hold your breath. There are States that are trying to make it mandatory that before a child can be enrolled in school the parents have to show they are here legally and so far that law ahs been struck down.
    • neiko 3 months ago
      I am not sure My Parents showed My I D and Birth certificates when I started School I always knew the were up to some thing! Maybe My real Parents were............
  • r. catesbeiana  •  3 months ago
    With all the abandonned "crib babies" in this country, why didn't she try to adopt one? How cruel and selfish to take someone's flesh and blood.
    • MARC 3 months ago
      prolly didn't have the $$ to buy a baby legally from the agencies...
    • Averageboomer 3 months ago
      "Prolly" - ? Is this a cross between probably and jolly?
    • Moomooshka 3 months ago
      Grump P, you have to be approved to adopt a child. She probably wasn't quite stable...
  • Boober  •  Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
    her real parents can never get back those childhood memories that was stolen from them nor ever erase the pain of what they went through all those years of not knowing what happened to their baby if would be enough to drive them crazy but thank god shes still alive
  • Tejas  •  3 months ago
    Article says "lack of Birth Certificate," So how did this "mom" register this child for school? Most states require a birth certificate to register the child for school.
    • CassadyH 3 months ago
      maybe she was homeschooled?
    • Kirstin 3 months ago
      Not all schools require that. My daughters were enrolled in our local public school without having to furnish birth certificates.
    • Lelu 3 months ago
      You said yourself "most" states, instead of "all" states.
  • boobookittysmom  •  Norfolk, Virginia  •  3 months ago
    WHO is Ann Pettway besides a rotten, stinking kidnapper who ruined the real parents' lives and the child's life that she kidnapped?! They can NEVER get back what she stole from them!
  • JL  •  Sacramento, California  •  3 months ago
    How sad she stole a baby and then mistreated her. What a horrible woman.
  • khendraghane  •  Montgomery, Alabama  •  3 months ago
    What I don't understand is how the child got to live a "normal" life for over twenty years. What about her birth documents & social security?
  • Jennifer  •  Los Angeles, California  •  3 months ago
    I wonder why her family never questioned why she suddenly showed up with a baby.
  • Shelia  •  Orlando, Florida  •  3 months ago
    The biological parents were so wise to set aside the money from lawsuits in a trust for their lost daughter. Such unselfish love didn't go unrewarded. Congratulations on finding your daughter!
  • nycliz2011  •  Hackensack, New Jersey  •  3 months ago
    She couldn't have babies so she steals one and then abuse her...20 years is not enough.
  • jimpsonseed  •  Philadelphia, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
    Selfish beotch. Hope she never sees the light of day again. Freakin' disgusting people who think they have the right to harm others in such a horrible way need to put somewhere where they'll never see sunshine again.
  • _  •  3 months ago
    What a piece of garbage. I can't imagine the heartbreak and agony those parents must have felt when their child was kidnapped. The kidnappers friends and family deserve to go to jail, too. Really? This woman just shows up with a kid one day and nobody questions where the baby came from? Someone should have called the cops on her 23 years ago.
  • Chuck  •  Piscataway, New Jersey  •  3 months ago
    Sounds like she was an abusive mom, so I think this girl now starts a life with her biological parents or one on her own.
  • JAMES  •  3 months ago
    After going through all that to get a child she still didn't have sense enough to treat her as a mother should. The main reason she got caught is because the girl knew in addition to not looking like her, this is not the way a mother should treat her child. That resentment sparked the search. Thieves and kidnappers are also stupid.
  • Sibelius  •  3 months ago
    You know, I'm suprised that some crazy court isn't awarding this kidnapper back child support for all the years the real parents never gave her any! LOL

    Can we just shoot this psycho?
  • CassadyH  •  3 months ago
    I do wonder though, how the "daughter" feels about this. She probably viewed the woman who kidnapped her as her mother, biological or not, seeing as how she was raised by her.I doubt that all of a sudden she just said s##%# this. That has to be tough, finding out that your "mother" isn't even closely related to you. I've got great respect for her, being able to move on from that.
  • Sofi  •  3 months ago
    If she wanted to have kids so much that she would steal one, she shouldnt hav been abusing her
  • youwantwhat  •  3 months ago
    This is one of the many cases over the years that has helped get better security in hospitals for newborns. Hope the woman and her real family can actually have a good relationship.
  • ัƒฮฑะผฮนฮทั”ั•ั• ะผฯƒฮทั•ั‚ั”ั  •  3 months ago
    Wait--how did the kidnapped girl go to school and live a normal life with no birth certificate or social security?
  • Daisy  •  3 months ago
    Just to sign a child up for kindergarten you need a birth certificate and social security number, same for a drivers licence. She must have found someone to forge those documents for her.