ABC News Blogs

Colorado Student Banned from Yearbook Over Racy Photo

What do you feel about this article?

A Colorado teenager whose yearbook picture was rejected for being too revealing is vowing to fight the ban with her high school’s administration, but the editors of the yearbook insist it was their decision alone on the photo.

The five student editors of the Durango High School yearbook in Durango, Col., told the Durango Herald they were the ones who made the call not to publish a picture of senior Sydney Spies posing in a short yellow skirt midriff and shoulder-exposing black shawl as her senior portrait.

“We are an award-winning yearbook. We don’t want to diminish the quality with something that can be seen as unprofessional,” student Brian Jaramillo told the paper on Thursday.

Spies was joined by her mother, Miki Spies, and a handful of fellow Durango High students and alumni in a protest outside the school Wednesday after, she said, administrators informed her the photo would not be permitted because it violated dress code.

“I feel like they aren’t allowing me to have my freedom of expression,” Spies told the Herald.  ”I think the administration is wrong in this situation, and I don’t want this to happen to other people.”

The five editors, who said their decision was unanimous, said Spies’ blame was misplaced, in both targeting the administration, and believing that it was a dress code issue.

They also offered her an opportunity to include the photo in the yearbook, just not as her senior photo.

“If she (Spies) chooses to, the picture will run as her senior ad, not her senior portrait,” Trujillo said.

Despite the clarification from her peers into how and why the decision was made, a meeting Spies initiated between herself, her mother, and the school’s principal, Diane Lashinsky, was held today as planned.

“The editors all turned their backs on me and changed their minds,” she told the Herald. “I really do feel like they were intimidated by the principal.”

Neither Spies nor the school responded to ABCNews.com‘s requests for comments today on the meeting’s outcome.

The Durango School District, which oversees the high school, issued the following statement to ABCNews.com

“The editors of Durango High School’s yearbook informed a senior student in December that her photo in question would not be included as a senior portrait in the yearbook and asked her to submit a replacement.   Durango School District 9-R’s administration supports this decision.”

Prior to today’s meeting, the Spies family told local media they planned to meet with a civil lawyer in Denver to review their daughter’s case.

Also Read
 
  • maximillian  •  Fulton, Mississippi  •  3 months ago
    of course her mother is backing her. If not for her mother she wouldnt think her "porn pic" was acceptable. the fruit dont fall far from the tree.
  • maximillian  •  Fulton, Mississippi  •  3 months ago
    a second grader told me a few days ago that she liked to dress like a hoochie sometimes. A #$%$ second grader. I wasnt even sure what a hoochie was
  • maximillian  •  Fulton, Mississippi  •  3 months ago
    i just viewed the "porn pic". good #$%$ grief what parent would even think about lettin their daughter pose for pics like that. do they think its playboy?
  • maximillian  •  Fulton, Mississippi  •  3 months ago
    frickin liberal #$%$
  • Richard  •  4 months ago
    On the plus side she will surely be voted most likely to be a porn star.
    • andrew c 4 months ago
      you must have experience in this field oh moral one
    • Richard 4 months ago
      No, just an observation.
    • Razed Catholic 4 months ago
      I'll bet she's already got some porn out there somewhere.
  • WF  •  4 months ago
    Parental fail.
    • cooper 4 months ago
      Always someone wanting to sue, that is what is wrong with our country now and causing so much intervention into our lives.
    • Ted 4 months ago
      Right on. Her mother shows her self-indulgence and ego-centrism through her daughter. What would we expect. I hope the majority of the school takes them to task. Another reason why the loser should pay court costs in many instances.
    • Deek W 4 months ago
      Exactly. Parent. FAIL!
  • Oscar V  •  4 months ago
    Nowadays, many teen girls think that having a "hooker look" is hot. Thanks to all those tv-shows and movies that promotes and celebrates this vulgar, tasteless and blatant trend.
  • Kim N.  •  Auburn, California  •  4 months ago
    Whichever attorney takes this case is nuts. A school yearbook is not required to publish anything a particular student wants published. Morons.
    • Garfy2008A 4 months ago
      Oh, I guess that means an ACLU lawyer.... they're ALL NUTS.
    • Belial De Sade 4 months ago
      If you open the door to question every and any photo of students & their activities IN the photos - you clearly will have a problem.

      If you're going to single out ONE student based on a few people's overreactions, there's nothing that can stop the singling out of ONE kid who sticks their tounge out, or wears a funny hat, or the color blue - it's all just subjective trivial crap that the school is fighting over. THIS is why the girl and her lawyer have a good case.
    • A Yahoo! User 4 months ago
      The color blue? The girl has no case. You can't always get what you want in life, including looking like a little #$%$ so the boys will like you. She's just angry she can't look hot in her yearbook so she can believe guys look at her and drool. LOL.
  • Joe  •  4 months ago
    I am so so glad that I and my wife are raising our daughter to develop her mind and to work toward good grades. There is time enough for everything else AFTER she is completely adult.

    I wish her "mom" had decided to be a parent.
    • Billy 4 months ago
      how old is your little girl? how many have you raised yet? my guess is your best years are yet to come,,,,good luck...
    • Claire 4 months ago
      Your kid will do whatever she wants and you cant stop it. Dont be a fool to think that she is perfect. You were young once too.
    • Steven C 4 months ago
      Claire, I hope you do not have, or will never have kids.
  • Christina  •  Massillon, Ohio  •  4 months ago
    Sue the school for your own vanity. Way to leave your underclassmen with a legacy of budget cuts and cancelled activities because the money had to be used for court costs. They will really thank you when they can dress trashy for the yearbook but maybe there won't be a yearbook next year due to cost cuts and new found liability issues.
  • William Fincher  •  Houston, Texas  •  4 months ago
    Freedom to express yourself comes with responsibility. This does not show responsibility on the student's part nor the parent. Great job editors.
  • KimP  •  4 months ago
    Stupid parents breeding and raising stupid kids.
  • Laurie  •  4 months ago
    omg i just looked at that girl's pic... what photographer & parent would let their daughter do a senior pic like that. that is very untasteful & way too revealing for a underage girl!
  • S  •  4 months ago
    All that's missing is her stripper pole!!! At least her parents know that she will be able to support herself after high school!
  • April  •  4 months ago
    She wanted her 15 mins. of fame and she got it. NEXT!
  • D  •  Lafayette, Indiana  •  4 months ago
    Misleading title. She wasn't banned in fact months ago she was told they needed an alternate picture. If she wasn't so spoiled and absolutely sure she'll get anything she wants she would have done the responsible thing and submitted a new one. But noooo she would rather throw a tantrum causing problems for everyone involved. We need to go back to beating these kids! It worked for our parents. When my generation grew up there werent any stabbings or shootings in schools and only an occasional pregnancy. Kids today have no clue how blessed they are with all the freedom they are given, instead they use that freedom to post naked pics or vids of the girls banging a room full of boys or of themselve beating someone unconscious.... God help us when they are running the country!
  • Milehigh  •  Durango, Colorado  •  4 months ago
    I live in Durango and am very pleased that the editors decided to stand by decency in this annual year book that they have worked long and hard hours on. It is in our Sunday paper today that this little gal and her mother are going to New York to be on the Today Show. Fully paid trip. By the way, the editors suggested that beings they would not publish this certain picture in the students pages, she could take out an ad in the back of the book and publish this picture there.
  • jen.  •  4 months ago
    yucccccccccck! that pic looks like its for an escort service in the back of a magazine! guess she wanted to be remembered as a tramp.
  • S  •  4 months ago
    Her Mom is basically pimping her daughter out. Disgusting.
  • Heather  •  4 months ago
    it is not about expressing yourself a senior picture is not about being sexy and it is not a Playboy cover shoot so I am glad it got banned. She should have little more self respect.