ABC News Blogs

Vacation Nightmare: Family Billed $11,000 For Streaming Movies

What do you feel about this article?

When the Gibsons of Weyburn, Saskatchewan, in Canada, returned home from a family vacation in Arizona, they found a $10,600 bill from their Internet provider - all because they had let their children stream movies on Netflix without realizing there would be roaming charges.

"The kids were getting bored," said Jason Gibson, in an interview with the CBC.  He had a so-called air card plugged into his laptop. And to ward off any whining, he let the children download "Shrek," "Curious George," and more, via cellular networks.

The only problem: when the Gibsons' children, Jayden and Sawyer, watched "Spider-Man," they downloaded about 400 megabytes of movie - at $6 per megabyte, since they were out of the country.

Their grandfather, John, was the one who first saw the bill. "He gave me a shout, told me about it, and my jaw hit the floor," Jason Gibson told a local paper, the Estevan Mercury.

This is not the largest cell phone bill on record.  Some others reported:

There was a Florida woman last October who said T-Mobile charged her $210,000 in roaming charges on a trip to Canada.

After the earthquake in Haiti, a FEMA employee from Maryland unknowingly ran up $30,000 in roaming charges in 2010 after she went to help with recovery efforts.

There was an Illinois man who complained he was charged $27,000 for streaming a Chicago Bears game while he was on a Caribbean cruise.  (The Bears won and, after a nasty, drawn-out battle, AT&T agreed to void the bill.)

Julius Genachowski, the chairman of the Federal Communications Commission, has called for new rules to force wireless companies to alert consumers before and when they start incurring excess charges.

"Surveys show that 30 million Americans - one out of every six mobile phone users - have experienced bill shock, and it's a real problem that we need to tackle," said Genachowski in October.

SaskTel, the phone company and Internet service provider the Gibsons use, said it reduced the bill by $9,600 - though that means the family still got a $1,000 lesson on the importance of reading the fine print.  (Canadian and U.S. dollars are roughly equal in value at the moment.)

"We are finding that our customers are using an increasing amount of bandwidth," said Michelle Englot, SaskTel's director of corporate affairs, in an email to ABC News. "We have had some instances of customers exceeding the data usage that is included within their plans but for the most part, our customers do understand what is included in their data plans and it is not typically this dramatic."

"It is very important that a customer understands what is included in their plan," she said. "Also, we recommend that any customer who is traveling outside of Canada should turn off their data while they are roaming to avoid any unexpected charges."

Data plans in the U.S. are different, but not a lot different. And service providers say it is incumbent on users to avoid wireless roaming when they travel.

Jason Gibson said he would pay the reduced bill, but he isn't happy about it.

"I think when you plug an air card in and you're roaming, it should probably say you're roaming on it," he told the CBC. "Some sort of warning signal that you're not supposed to be using it in the States."

Also Read
 
  • REK  •  St Louis, Missouri  •  3 months ago
    The joke is on all the people paying these charges at any price. When I grew up, we did not have these services and I still do not need them. The day I live my life with a cell phone in my hand is the day I will be ready to leave this earth. The need to live on a electronic device only proves you have never lived. Make life an adventure not a internet experience. LOL, I know all you young people think I am crazy, but maybe you should go 60 days with no phone.....
    • MICHAEL 3 months ago
      i think you are totally right
    • Barb Patrice 3 months ago
      Me too.. only reason I even own a cell phone is so I can be contacted if there is a family emergency. It's always in my purse if I'm out of the house, But I don't think I've actually used it to call anyone more that twice in the last year.
    • Sarah Jessica Parker' ... 3 months ago
      Unfortunately, you are of a different generation. You cannot be young in this society and not have a cell phone or be hooked into the Internet in some way. (Note that this does not mean you have to you "live" on either them - simply that they are technological tools one needs to have in order to communicate and compete in the 21st century.)

      Something tells me had someone told you to give up your landline telephone, radio, and indoor plumbing back in the 1950's or 1960's or whatever, you would have thought that was crazy. Same thing.
  • nutcases all around  •  3 months ago
    Should people know they are paying roaming fees when in another country? Yes.
    Should phone companies be required to let people know they are racking up an obscene bill? Yes.
  • Christy  •  3 months ago
    why spend the money to go on vacation when you are just sticking the kids in front of the tv anyway?
    • Lissy 3 months ago
      I figured it was during the trip to the vacation that they did this-- IE while driving.
    • marshhawk 3 months ago
      When our parents drove to vist the grandparents. We the kids brought book s, we drew , did coloring books, and most important pillows to sleep on.We played games like to count how many cows you see or spot a out -state-plate.
      That was along time ago .
    • marshhawk 3 months ago
      The pillow fights we had in the back of the car were the greatest. Do not tell Mom that.
  • R K  •  Vantaa, Finland  •  3 months ago
    When I moved to Canada for 3 months, the phone company told me that I could use a calling card they sent to me in the mail. If used the card, I would be billed a few cents a minute for calls between Canada and America. They said I should not disconnect my phone in Michigan because the calling card was part of my "international plan". When I got home, the phone company sent me a bill for several thousand dollars. I was outraged. The total cost of my calls in Canada was only 300 dollars, which I had paid on calling card invoice. I went round and round with the phone company and finally told them to stuff it. I switched my phone service to another company. That was 14 year ago. For years, the original phone company attacked my credit rating. I have kept the calling and the original letter explaining how the calling card with the international plan was supposed to work in hopes those boneheads will take it to court. But no, they would just rather harrass me forever. Good luck stupid phone company. I have moved to Europe and my credit report means NOTHING to the folks over here.
    • KRM 3 months ago
      You're calling card only covers the cost of long distance and making the call. But if you used your cell phone, then the bill that you got is for roaming because you were in Canada. You're going to get that too. The phone company wasn't at fault.
    • Orangensaft 3 months ago
      If she's talking about an incident 14 years ago and with calling cards, I doubt this has to do with cell phones and roaming. (Those were the days, though, huh? Dealing with long distance carriers? Talk about your scams...)
    • William 3 months ago
      I'm glad you are in Finland. Makes us both happy.
  • Denise  •  Portage, Michigan  •  3 months ago
    Board games anyone?? LOL
    • guillotinetheelites 3 months ago
      throw out your electronics, tv's move to the woods and i bet your family will be happier/healthier than ever.
    • Grandma 3 months ago
      That's what I thought, too!! LOL
    • Ell 3 months ago
      Happier? SMARTER for sure. And smarter makes happier in the long run.
  • Mr. RD  •  3 months ago
    So he takes his kids on vaction and lets them sit in a room to watch a laptop..you could have done that at home.
  • ADK 4ever  •  Warwick, New York  •  3 months ago
    To me a vacation is about experiencing something new, a new place, new people, etc., or at least something out of the usual daily routine. I can't understand people who go on vacation have to be surrounded by everything they would have at home. Kids "bored"? Obviously sunk into a world of passive entertainment that they can't function without.
    • james s 3 months ago
      They were vacationing in Arizona...sorry I lived there for 3 years...it's boring.
  • Die Zimtzicke  •  3 months ago
    Read the fine print, and for God sake if your kids are bored on vacation, DO SOMETHING WITH THEM! Who goes on vacation to watch movies?
  • TH  •  3 months ago
    Sounds to me like people need to start buying some of the card games like Uno, Phase 10, etc and taking them on the trips to provide their kids some entertainment.
  • Grandma  •  3 months ago
    ASSUME that when you go from one country to another, nothing will be FREE!! Oh, and always check what your plan entails BEFORE using the tech outside your basic area!!

    Bored on vacation?? Go for walks.. do some 'treasure hunts'. If near a store and it's raining, buy a couple BOARD games. Go buy a few cheap dvd's. Go buy crayons and coloring books. Scissors, paper, and glue do wonders, too!! What about books? And anything bought could ALWAYS be donated to the motel/hotel if they can't be taken back home with you!! What about a PARK to run off energy? They downloaded Curious George so it appears they weren't teens!! LOL

    We grew up without streaming videos, so did our kids. Sure, they got bored, but SO what!! (Not often, though.) That's the time creativity begins!! A child who never gets bored has too much on their plate.
  • William  •  Detroit, Michigan  •  3 months ago
    Umm... really?! You didn't know that there would be roaming charges when you were in ANOTHER COUNTRY?! Being in a boarder state with Canada, I am still aware that once I go over the bridge (or tunnel) I will be charged roaming fees. I turn off my phone, just so I will not even recieve a call. I urge carriers to lower, but not drop the fees all together, for first time offenders. There has to be a charge for just being dumb. Some say stupidty should hurt, well it can hurt your pocket book.
  • Scooter  •  Buffalo, New York  •  3 months ago
    People can read but they don't choose to --
  • kathy g  •  Livingston, New Jersey  •  3 months ago
    how about a book or other non electronic way to keep them non bored
  • Jeff  •  Dallas, Texas  •  3 months ago
    You have a laptop, stop at Walmart and buy a $5 movie for the kids to watch or better yet bring some with you since you know you have whiny kids.
  • False Flag  •  Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
    next time he'll hand the kids some books instead of letting them tune out and drool in front of movies.
  • Curmudgeon  •  Dayton, Ohio  •  3 months ago
    Next time leave the electronic babysitters at home.
  • erok  •  3 months ago
    In a side note, these internet providers skimp on their 35% corporate tax rate. #$%$ all corporations who act like they care about anyone ... even their own employees ... while screwing everyone else in the process.
  • robert  •  3 months ago
    My goodness what's so wrong with being bored? These kids and (mostly the parents) are so afraid of the kids being bored they'll go to any lengths to keep them stimulated. What happened to good old fashioned daydreaming, that's what I used to do when I got bored.
  • Diana B  •  New York, New York  •  3 months ago
    I'm going to remember this article every time I see another techie herald "the end of the DVD is near". DVD's are pretty archaic and so 1999, and they migght have saved this guy thousands of dollars.
  • kf  •  3 months ago
    It would have been a lot cheaper to buy the kids some used DVDs.