Could a Blood Test Help Spot Depression?

FRIDAY, Feb. 3 (HealthDay News) -- Depression can be a tough condition to diagnose accurately, but new research suggests that someday a blood test might help.

It's not clear how much the test might cost, and it needs more stringent validation before it will be ready to be used in medical offices. Still, "it appears that these results are promising, after decades of research into finding a biological test for depression," said study author Dr. George Papakostas, an associate professor of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School.

The study was funded by the Ridge Diagnostics Co. and appeared in a recent issue of the journal Molecular Psychiatry.

It may seem like depression is an easy condition to diagnose and doesn't need a test to verify that it exists, but Papakostas said there are several ways that a blood-based depression test might be helpful.

For one, he said, a test could help doctors who aren't as experienced in psychiatric disorders. Also, he said, a test may provide assistance to doctors who aren't sure about the proper diagnosis of a patient: "This could be of help to them, in terms of guiding them in one way or another," he said.

Yet another use for a test would be to verify that a patient has depression, and therefore help him or her accept the diagnosis. "The majority of patients diagnosed with depression have no problem accepting the need for treatment," Papakostas said. However, "there is a minority of patients who feel that validation of an underlying process is helpful," he added.

In their study, Papakostas and his team gave a blood test to 36 patients with depression and 43 people who weren't depressed. The test looked for levels of nine different "biomarkers" in the blood that are associated with depression. These biomarkers are linked to inflammatory processes, the development and maintenance of brain cells, and interactions between brain structures associated with the stress response and other functions.

The researchers found that the test correctly identified patients with depression 91 percent of the time; the rest of the time it gave a false-negative diagnosis (it failed to spot the depression). The test correctly identified patients who weren't depressed about 81 percent of the time, giving false-positives the rest of the time.

The next step is to try to confirm these findings through further research, Papakostas said.

He didn't know how much the test might eventually cost, but he said it won't be as high as thousands of dollars and should be more akin to routine blood tests.

The test appears to detect inflammation in the brain, which has been linked to depression, Papakostas said. "That really doesn't surprise researchers. Chronic inflammation has been tied to a number of other illnesses in the kidneys, lungs and heart," he noted.

One outside expert said such a test would be welcome.

Dr. Michelle Riba, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Michigan who's familiar with the findings, said a blood test for depression could be helpful in several ways.

For one, it would be useful to identify people, especially children and adolescents, who are prone to depression and try to prevent it, she said.

Also, she said, a test could help give physicians insight into how depression treatments are working over time.

More information

For more on depression, had to the U.S. National Library of Medicine.

 

16 comments

  • Aphid  •  3 months ago
    This is awesome news. Too often depression hides under the guise of hypothyroidism, chronic pain, menopause, insomnia, aging, shyness, a "bad personality," or quirky "moodiness." It is a SEPARATE, PHYSIOLOGICAL condition that needs to be addressed apart from any conditions that may co-occur. A blood test to identify its presence will save precious time in diagnosis and access to treatment. For example, a physician who finds, via an objective blood test, that a patient suffers from both poor thyroid function and clinical depression, can address both issues when offering treatment and medications. Also, lab results positive for depression will help enormously to validate the existence of this debilitating disease, and remove its stigma in the minds of both patients and the general public.
    • JaniceG 3 months ago
      Amen, it sure takes a lot from peoples lives.
    • skye 3 months ago
      Totally agree!
    • Moon Unit 3 months ago
      Depression only holds a stigma among the ignorant. Why kowtow to them? Any knowledgeable doctor knows to rule out medical causes of depression.
  • beowulf  •  3 months ago
    More big pharma rhetoric.. when profit is involve 'thet' have the cure. Look into some real treatments.

    'Exercise Cures for Depression' (E How)

    'The top five foods for beating depression' (natural news)

    'Exercise and Depression: Endorphins, Reducing Stress, and More' (Web MD)

    'Depression and mental disorders can be prevented and treated with simple healing foods' (natural news)

    be well... and stay true to yourself.
    • looking for truth 3 months ago
      It's frightening that it's bad enough a person with a temporary trauma (job loss, death in the family,etc) can be labeled and stigmatized for the rest of his or her life, but now there is a chance somebody in a lab can make a mistake and then the doctor can use this as a tool to give somebody treatment who is not really depressed.
    • Audrey 3 months ago
      They can't force it on someone.
    • beowulf 3 months ago
      @ looking for truth

      That's not only the case with depression diagnosis.. but almost all diagnosis.. BIG Pharma has the medical community by the tight and curlies.
  • KCP  •  3 months ago
    Many of the markers the article notes as being symptoms of depression have quite recently being discovered to be the result of Vitamin D deficiency. But no one whats to look in that direction because big Pharma, the researchers and the Dr.'s will LOSE MONEY if they do...

    Bottle of 500 Vitamin D3 5000 U/I ..... $6.00
    • KCP 3 months ago
      Just to clarify, I'm not saying Vitamin D is a cure all. But for many people who get a blanket diagnosis of depression, I suggest a blood test for your Vitamin D level. The reason you feel fatigued, brain fog, aches and pains (inflammation) and thus, feel down in the dumps and depressed is because may be depressed. Correct that, and the mind might have nothing to feel "blue" about.
    • supersweetipie 3 months ago
      Thanks for the info. Its really helpful. Unfortunately, alot of people do have genetically based depression. Thanks for distinguishing. Fish oil is also a miracle drug.
    • a Yahoo! User 3 months ago
      Super how do we really know the genetic link isn't low D, we don't. I guarantee anyone that suffers from Depression and takes a supplement will feel better than any prescription big pharma makes. It even helped with my anorexia and fatigue.
  • Sub Missive  •  3 months ago
    I truly hope this test works. One of the benefits not mentioned is that it would help distinguish the difference between clinical depression and situational depression. Too many people are now on mood altering drugs who shouldn't be, just because they were going through a rough patch.
    • Moon Unit 3 months ago
      Good-luck trying to split the mind and body. I do agree drugs are over-prescribed, but the situational depression of which you speak may be very debilitating to a person. If a blood test says he's not "depressed", what then? If you are an insurance company, will you pay for treatment? Are all blood tests 100% accurate? What if you are told the test is negative and the test was wrong?
    • Sub Missive 3 months ago
      Moon, you make some very good points. Especially about insurance. Yes, situational depression can be very debilitating, but if treated correctly, it is short term (so to speak). And I could very well see insurance not paying if a blood test came back negative. (They will try to get out of paying everything they can!)
  • H  •  3 months ago
    Far too much money is involved AND Drs use the drugs for Off Label Use for pain and a dozen other reasons and unlike most diseases and medications There Is No Way to measure serotonin levels.

    This is not good medicine as they are messing with brain chemicals without a way of knowing what they are doing to a person SHORT term or Long term and I blame the FDA for looking at profits for pills when Most people need exercise in the sun and people to speak to not sitting all night on HERE then complaining to their Dr how bad they feel.
  • Robert W  •  Denver, Colorado  •  3 months ago
    another way to see if there is inflammation is through testing for the TBARS (Thiobarbituric Acid Reactive Substances) levels. This is an indication of the level of oxidative stress which has been liked to many maladies including depression. I was severely depressed for a good part of my life until I started taking a product called Protandim which induces the body to create massive amounts of antioxidants, reducing oxidative stress. I have never felt better in my life, I feel free for the first time.
  • Marlene  •  3 months ago
    Personally, I don't believe a thing coming out of Harvard! They don't give a darn about us, they are just after every last dollar we have! 10 to 1 odd the comapanies that sponsored this, Ridge Diagnostics Co, got a government grant to do it, but they will make all the money, is see at least one more Harvard or former Harvard guy is at that company.
    Now Lonna J. Williams is not out of Harvard, but I wonder if she launched those hip replacements when she worked for Johnson & Johnson, the ones where half of them fail. Nevermind, won my own bet!
    Perry Renshaw is a co-founder of Ridge Diagnostics Inc. and serves as its Chief Medical Officer. Dr. Renshaw serves as Member of Scientific Advisory Board of Tetragenex Pharmaceuticals, Inc. He serves as Director of Magnetic Resonance at the Utah Brain Institute, University of Utah. He is a Professor of Psychiatry, University of Utah School of Medicine, and a USTAR Investigator. Formerly, Dr. Renshaw was Professor of Psychiatry at the Harvard School of Medicine and Director ... of the McClean Hospital Brain Imaging Center. Dr. Renshaw provides us with exceptional expertise in MDD, PTSD and other neuropsychiatric disorders. He also provides access to academic medicine and patient samples. He is the Principal Investigator or Co-Investigator on federally funded grants and industry-sponsored clinical trials.
  • skye  •  3 months ago
    This would be a wonderful tool because it would shut up the naysayers who claim depression or other brain disorders are character "weaknesses" and not "real". Particularly, in instances of postpartum depression, when hormonal levels are in flux, yet there are still people who will not seek treatment. A test administered regularly, could detect and legitimize this illness.
    • Moon Unit 3 months ago
      Depression and many mental illnesses are legitimate conditions. Why do you need validated by a medical test? The problem with the medical profession is that they have abdicated their knowledge and rely primarily on expensive medical tests.
    • skye 3 months ago
      The test would be valuable because it would legitimize the illness. I have seen people refuse seeking help when they plainly needed it because they themselves, and others around them had the idea that it was just a weak character trait to admit to having issues. Of course, that is totally wrong, but some people are just ignorant to the fact of depression being a real illness. If you could get rid of the myth and stigma factors, then people who need it may feel more free and less embarrassed to seek help and get treatment. The test would provide that sense of freedom from shame to those people.
  • squishy  •  3 months ago
    Sounds like a good thing.
  • Averageboomer  •  3 months ago
    A comprehensive interview would tell the same by asking about sleep, thoughts, tearfulness, ability to focus and concentrate, etc.
  • J A  •  Monroe, Louisiana  •  3 months ago
    I suffer from depression and can say if you need a blood test to tell you tour depressed then your probably not depressed? Maybe?
  • Wyatt Earp  •  3 months ago
    Depression, a "condition" diagnosed by someone "practicing" medicine. No chance for a cure (EVER) since the makers of Prozac, Wellbutrin, Paxil, etc are multi-millionaires now. WHAT A SCAM.
  • mac marine  •  Sacramento, California  •  3 months ago
    I know I'm depressed because I am depressed! This is why I take anti depressents stupid. I don't need a blood test to tell me when I cut my finger either! I am not a friggin democrate and I don't need me goverment to point out the obvious. Jezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz!
  • A Yahoo! User  •  3 months ago
    I know for a fact that blood tests can spot depression, because after my friend blew his brains out, all that blood on the wall was a sure sign of depression...
  • Guy  •  3 months ago
    Just another way to peddle prozac. Let's face it - America is a nation of hypochondriacs. People around the world live and lead happy lives without all the worrying, hand-wringing and medicine cabinets full of unneeded snake oil.
  • L  •  Baltimore, Maryland  •  3 months ago
    Problems of privatization, irresponsibility, disabilities of government attorneys and judicial/legal/court personnel are very serious, expanding, local- nationwide- global; exporting injustice overseas; Rockville city, Montgomery County, Maryland state; New Jersey Monmouth County, Judge Robert McLeod (private attorney), Judge Patricia Bueno Cleary, Prosecutor (private attorney) Patrick Healy, police David Dโ€™Arcy.