Sugarland Says Negligence Claims Against Them For Stage Collapse 'Sensationalize the Disaster'

Grammy-nominated country duo Sugarland said the lawsuit that states they are partially responsible for the tragic stage collapse last summer that killed seven, is actually people trying to "sensationalize the disaster."

In a statement to ABC News, Sugarland's manager Gail Gellman said, "Sadly when a tragedy occurs, people want to point fingers and try to sensationalize the disaster. The single most important thing to Sugarland, are their fans. Their support and love over the past nine years has been unmatched. For anyone to think otherwise is completely devastating to them."

Moments before Sugarland -- comprised of Jennifer Nettles and Kristian Bush -- was to perform a concert at the Indiana State Fair on Aug. 13, a powerful storm blew through the area, and a huge gust of wind ripped down the stage scaffolding. Seven people were killed and dozens were injured -- one of which was an 8-year-old girl.

Numerous victims of the stage collapse filed a massive civil lawsuit on Nov. 22 in Marion Superior Court in Indianapolis, claiming Sugarland and the companies involved with the construction of the stage were negligent and contributed to the accident.

According to the lawsuit, the plaintiffs, which include the families or the estates of four people killed and dozens who were injured, allege that Sugarland, Live Nation, Mid-America Sound Corp. and other events companies failed to provide a safe stage area and ignored inclement weather concerns.

The concert should have been canceled and the crowd evacuated, the lawsuit stated.

On Feb. 16, Sugarland's lawyers responded to the claims and denied all accusations against the band, saying Sugarland had nothing to do with the stage's construction. Among their many other defenses, said that "some or all of the Plaintiffs' claimed injuries resulted from their own fault," because some "failed to exercise due care for their own safety" or "knowingly and voluntary assumed and/or incurred the risk of injury to themselves."

The band's lawyers also denied Sugarland was responsible for deciding whether or not to cancel the concert because of weather concerns, calling it an "Act of God."

"The incident at issue in this litigation resulted from a gust of wind of unprecedented intensity, which caused a structure that may have been improperly designed, maintained and/or inspected to fail. As such, this was a true accident or Act of God," the response reads.

The Indiana Occupational Safety and Health Administration conducted a six-month investigation after the incident. Their report, released on Feb. 8, found that the heavy equipment supporting the stage was not properly built and that Mid-America Sound Corp., an events production company that constructed the roof and rigging used to hold the lights and sound equipment, had not taken appropriate measures to inspect the stage area.

IOSHA determined that Sugarland did not employ the workers who built the stage and therefore was not responsible for the incident, but fined Mid-America $63,000 for three serious violations of industry standards.

A spokeswoman for Mid-America told ABC News that the company had not yet paid the fine, and is meeting with IOSHA next week to discuss the report.

Sugarland's attorneys are now seeking a jury trial, but declined to comment to ABC News about the allegations.

Lead vocalist Jennifer Nettles told "Good Morning America" anchor Robin Roberts in a November interview that while she did not feel a sense of responsibility for what happened, she wept after hearing some fans were killed in the stage collapse.

"I mean, there are no, there are no words for that kind of, of tragedy," Nettles told Roberts, at the time. "We are forever connected to those people, because of the evening that we shared, and the moment that we shared, and the tragedy that we shared."

Prior to the moment when the stage fell, the band was waiting underneath it, and was uninjured in the accident.

"Everything suddenly looked dark, and then wind, and then a crashing sound, a horrible metal torquing, twisting sound," Nettles recalled. "And then the ceiling of the dressing room torqued and shuddered, and everyone went to the wall, because we didn't know what was happening, because we couldn't see, we're underneath. And then, we all just all stood there, waiting to know what was happening. ... Obviously, once we realized what happened, everybody's on their radios, and it's madness."

ABC News' John Palacio and the Associated Press contributed to this report.

Also Read
 
  • Gr8Flood  •  2 months ago
    This is going to sound a little harsh, but it is what I see. The parents of the 8 year old and those responsible for the others who died feel guilty that they did not protect their loved ones so to live with themselves they must find fault someplace else. They say the band should have cancelled the show, but one could also say that the people standing there should have left. Fact is it was caused by weather and not the fault of anyone. Try to heal...not blame.
    • Toll_Free 2 months ago
      I hope you have no political aspirations. That whole making sense, telling the truth, telling people they have to be responsible just won't wash in todays climate.

      SOMEONE else MUST be responsible for their stupidity..... How DARE you say they should know enough to get out of the weather (which my Mom taught me almost 40 years ago)
    • Linda 2 months ago
      Amen!
    • Karen S 2 months ago
      This is the truth...Who in their right mind wants to stand in the high winds & rain to see any concert? Not me....I have spent money and left before the show many times because I have been to hot or to cold to stay it is called common sense. Some have it others do not and those lacking it are the ones looking for a big pay day.
  • bigbuckeyefan  •  Columbus, Ohio  •  2 months ago
    ok if the weather was so bad why didnt people leave? do they not have a weather channel in indy? im not understanding how sugarland is at fault..
    • TIMEX 2 months ago
      the band made them compelled to do it! plus the price of addmission is a killer these days! So like they say I am going to stand here even if it kills me!
    • JulieAnn 2 months ago
      Timex, what the hell,Sugarland MADE THEM COMPELLED TO DO IT. Wow REALLY.they tied them up and made the people not move...so stupid of a comment
    • Jaye 2 months ago
      Yes TIMEX..you are a #$%$ you twit.
  • JMS  •  2 months ago
    There is practically NO WAY to build a portable stage that would withstand a tornado. If that is what IOSHA is going to require then that will be the end of outdoor concerts. No band or promoter could afford the stage or the libility. This is a matter of some people trying to cash in on a disaster.
    • James Andrews 2 months ago
      This wasn't a portable stage that collapsed. it may have been a rental stage, but it wasn't like a stagelind truck type stage. That is what I call a prtable stage. This was much heavier duty and more labor intensive to build.
    • James Andrews 2 months ago
      And I know, because I am in that business.
    • DJ Spoke Wrench 2 months ago
      It wasn't a tornado.
  • Alicia  •  2 months ago
    What happened was a great tragedy. Tornado's produce strong winds which can and do destroy things in their paths. No stage would be able to withstand that. Thats why its called an "Act of God".
    • Smur_dog 2 months ago
      Well said... This was not Sugarlands fault or anyones for that matter. I've lived through a tornado, If it wants to take something out.. IT WILL!!! Nothing can stop it. I feel really bad for the people that were injured and killed, it isn't anything anyone wants to go through. When you are dealing with an outdoor event. The audiance has to take some responsability to watch for the weather, and use common sense to stay or leave.. I feel Sugarland did the right thing by coming back and doing a free concert for the people.. They could have just said too bad, and gone on with their lives... But not them.. They have HEART!!! Try not to look back, Try and look forward... When it is your time to go.. Nothing can stop it.. IT's Sad but true.. Bobbie Weiss Svacha.
    • Robert 2 months ago
      It's an act of nature. There is no God.
    • Jason 2 months ago
      Robert - Wow how do you live from day to day. Your life must me miserable with that belief. I will pray for you.
  • Silly Walk  •  2 months ago
    In any public event, stages have to be designed by engineers. They follow state code. The code does not take the extreme case of a tornado in account otherwise no wood building would be built in the US. But someone was in charge of security. And when tornado warning came, knowing the stage was not designed to withstand a tornado, they should have evacuated immediately.
    The artist’s decision was irrelevant. They sure bear a moral responsibility, but they were not in charge of the venue. The sheriff should have escorted them off stage.
    • A Yahoo! User 2 months ago
      There was no tornado warning only high wind warning after the fact it came in so fast even the weather people couldn,t warn fast enough.
    • Matthew 2 months ago
      More mid-western hokey
    • jon 2 months ago
      They weren't "on stage", they were under the stage waiting for their time to perform.
  • Kat  •  2 months ago
    The fans chose to stay out there and I am sure they could tell the weather was turning bad. I cannot believe they are blaming the band for this.
  • AJFKDEM  •  Elk City, Oklahoma  •  2 months ago
    I am fiddling with my gun, and shoot myself in the foot. I suee thye gunmaker and the ammo supplier.
    I get a cup of coffee and spill it on myself, and sue the coffee maker, because they did their job and served hot coffee.

    Only in America!
  • frank h  •  Conway, South Carolina  •  2 months ago
    Thats what we have become...the land of frivilous lawsuits.
  • MichaelP  •  Dayton, Ohio  •  2 months ago
    It's really sad that Sugarland has to become the victims of blatant sensationalism, after the disaster of the stage collapse at the Indiana State Fair. My guess is not only will the lawsuit against the band be dismissed, because of all the frivolities involved, but they're going to fire their attorneys for accusing the fans of playing the role in an incident that they were not at fault for at all. Whomever the hell is sensationalizing this calamity needs to have a 2x4 taken to their heads for this.
  • A Yahoo! User  •  2 months ago
    Act of God nothing more but maybe a few idiots who didn,t care about there own lifes to get a way from the area when it looked bad i live in indiana i know what that storm was like it came so fast no time to responed so is sugarland the problem here i say noway it was a act of GOD.
  • Josh G  •  Denver, Colorado  •  2 months ago
    ummm we dont control the weather people thats god and mother natures department. This is just people that are looking for the right person to sue but sadly there really is no one to sue but they will blame the band since they have the most money
  • Walter  •  Harlingen, Texas  •  2 months ago
    When people sue they always include anyone and everyone that had involved in the situation. This includes installer and all. I feel that sometimes people that sue go beyond the limits in order to obtain a larger sum of money to offset thier loss or injury. Then there are those that would sue thier own family if they could get some money out of it. I feel sorry for those that lost love ones and those that were hurt.
  • GretchenW  •  Seattle, Washington  •  2 months ago
    Blame, blame, blame! And try to get as much money out of it as you can!!! *Insert sarcasm*

    Yes, the constuction co. that built the stage has some fault in this. But it was a stormy night! LEAVE! Common sense must have blown away with the wind that night.

    I am a concert goer and I have left outdoor events due to bad weather. I feel for the families who lost loved ones but come on...place some responsibility on their actions as well. Going after the band for MORE money isn't going to solve anything...but making your pocket book bigger....sad.
  • frank h  •  Conway, South Carolina  •  2 months ago
    I farted and accidently #$%$ my pants......act of God???????????? Who can I sue????????
  • joe  •  2 months ago
    it's all about the money
  • Tj  •  2 months ago
    I would imagine the stage was erected according to local and national code standards. To me this was an act of God as it were. It was very unfortunate and a tragedy. My thoughts and prayers are with all involved.
  • Billy  •  Pennsauken, New Jersey  •  2 months ago
    I took my 10 year old daughter to an outdoor concert, and a lightening storm started rolling in. I got her the hell out of there...before anything bad could happen. Personal responsibility plays a huge role in this sad disaster, and anyone at that OUTDOOR concert had a responsibility to themselves and their loved ones...it was sad....it was an act of God, the Band was not responsible...period.
  • Pam  •  Spring, Texas  •  2 months ago
    The victim in the video states "...for them to keep us there..." I'm sorry, I've never been to a concert where they shackled you to your seat when you showed up to keep you from leaving? The fans here had full visibility of the sky. The fans knew or should have known the weather situation was worsening. If the fans CHOSE to stay at an outdoor concert with the obvious worsening of the weather situation...the fans here ARE partly responsible. If they are not responsible for their choices and ignorance of weather then the artists who were in their dressing rooms with no direct line of sight to the sky surely cannot be held responsible either.
  • Ange  •  Vancouver, Canada  •  2 months ago
    Shoulda coulda woulda... if you felt it was unsafe to be there... you could have left.
  • PitViper  •  2 months ago
    When concert goers saw the inclement weather coming in and it looked pretty dark and foreboding, I would've gotten my arse outta there. Whether or not the concert was cancelled wouldn't have mattered. People would've hung around trying to get a glimpse of someone or something and the deaths might have been even higher. To blame SugarLand or anyone else is ridiculous.
Loading...