Banana Mural Riles Indiana Town

By Alana Abramson

The mural on the house is clearly a banana. But is it art? Or an advertisement?

That is the question facing a town in Indiana as it weighs whether or not the house can keep its banana mural.

Yossarian Gutwein painted the picture of a banana on a house near Purdue University in West Lafayette. The house is in a prominent area of town and needed a paint job, Stuart Gutwein, who is Yossarian Gutwein's cousin, told ABC News. Gutwein's law firm handles legal issues for Granite Management, which manages the property.

But the logo for Granite Management is also a banana. Consequently, it has become a sticking point as to whether the painting is also serving as an advertisement for Granite Management.

Eric Burns, the attorney for the city council, explained to ABC News that if the mural was unquestionably artwork, the town would not be getting involved. It would constitute a form of free expression protected by the First Amendment. But because the banana is also the logo of Granite Management, it could be construed as advertising, which can be subject to commercial regulation under a county ordinance.

"There is clearly a commercial element to it," said Burns. "Right now, we are just trying to develop the facts about what is behind it."

Dave Buck, the city engineer, has called a meeting for the end of the month to discuss the matter. No decisions will be made until then. Buck could not immediately be reached for comment.

View Comments (984)

Recommended for You

  • 6-Year-Old 'Fighting for His Life' After South Carolina Elementary School Shooting, Official Says

    A 6-year-old boy is "fighting for his life" today after being critically wounded in the shooting at an elementary school in Townville, South Carolina, according to the city's fire chief, who spoke at a news conference this afternoon. Jacob Hall, a kindergarten student at Towville Elementary…

    Good Morning America26 mins ago
  • Woman Killed in NJ Transit Crash Identified as 34-Year-Old Hoboken Resident Fabiola Bittar de Kroon

    The woman who was killed in a New Jersey Transit train crash this morning has been identified by officials as 34-year-old Hoboken resident Fabiola Bittar de Kroon, a mother with a vibrant career who moved to the United States from Brazil with her family. De Kroon was not a passenger on the train…

    Good Morning America
  • 13-Year-Old Twins Honored With '911 Hero Awards' for Helping Mom Deliver Baby Sister at Home

    A pair of twin sisters from South Carolina were honored at their middle school this week for bravely assisting their mom with the unexpected birth of their baby sister. Nykiaya (Kiaya) Williams-Brown and Nykailyn (Kailyn) Williams-Brown, both 13, each received a "911 Hero Award" for stepping in…

    Good Morning America
  • Emergency Responders Describe Aftermath of NJ Transit Crash in Hoboken

    Emergency workers piled into a bar located a short distance from the Hoboken Terminal in New Jersey to eat, rest and chat about the destruction caused by a New Jersey Transit commuter train that crashed this morning, killing one and injuring more than 100 others. Texas Arizona, the bar, provided…

    Good Morning America
  • Lady Gaga Will Perform at Super Bowl Halftime Show

    Lady Gaga will headline next year's Super Bowl halftime show. The National Football League and the singer made the announcement today on Twitter. Super Bowl LI will be held at NRG Stadium in Houston, Texas, on Feb. 5, 2017.

    Good Morning America
  • James Hinchcliffe and Sharna Burgess Prep for Their New 'Dancing With the Stars' Number

    Hinchcliffe and Burgess were tasked with theming their dance to "Paramour," Cirque du Soleil's first foray onto Broadway. Speaking from inside the Lyric Theatre, Burgess said she credits the couple's consistently high scores to Hinchcliffe's split-second attention to detail (thanks to his career…

    Good Morning America
  • Firefighters Rescue Dog Trapped at Bottom of 40-Foot-Deep Well

    Firefighters saved the life of an elderly dog after he somehow fell down a 40-foot-deep well in McDonough, Georgia, according to county officials. The yellow Labrador retriever named Bama was "desperately trying to keep [his] head above water," when animal control officers found him on Monday…

    Good Morning America
  • President Obama Welcomes Team USA to the White House

    President Obama welcomed Team USA -- about 600 Olympians and Paralympians -- to the White House today, congratulating them not only for their gold, silver and bronze medals but also for their representation of a diverse set of ideals that inspired Americans during the Rio Summer Games.

    Good Morning America
  • 'Real Housewives of Atlanta': New Trailer Hints at New Season

    The "Real Housewives of Atlanta" have been really busy in the southern city.Bravo just released a super-trailer for Season 9 that can satisfy fans until the series returns Nov. 6.The more than two-minute trailer hints at which alliances are broken, what new friendships have been forged and who's…

    Good Morning America
  • Princess Charlotte Walks and Talks at Military Children's Party in Canada Alongside Prince George

    Prince George and Princess Charlotte made their second appearance of their family’s eight-day tour of Canada today at a children’s party for military families. Charlotte also excitedly bounded towards a dog named Moose while she and her big brother, George, played with a bubble squirt gun. …

    Good Morning America
  • NJ Transit Passengers Said Crash 'Sounded Like a Bomb'

    Witnesses describe the harrowing scene this morning after a New Jersey Transit commuter train crashed into a platform at Hoboken Terminal in northern New Jersey, killing at least one person and seriously injuring others. Corey Futterman was riding in one of the last cars of the train but was not…

    Good Morning America
  • Prince William, Princess Kate Inspect Steam Train Above Lake in Canada

    Prince William and Princess Kate left their staff in a momentary state of panic Wednesday when they slid across a railroad bridge perched high above the icy waters of Canada’s Lake Bennett. William and Kate, both 34, made the impromptu visit to the White Pass steam train in Carcross, Yukon, on the…

    Good Morning America
  • Solemn Atmosphere in Parts of North Jersey After Train Crash

    A solemn atmosphere fell upon parts of northern New Jersey today as victims from the morning's commuter train crash were transported to area hospitals and investigators gathered at the site to try to determine the cause. A normally bustling area outside of the historic Hoboken train station was…

    Good Morning America
  • 2 People in Critical Condition in NJ Train Crash

    At least 51 people are receiving treatment at Jersey City Medical Center after a New Jersey Transit commuter train crashed into Hoboken Terminal this morning, according to hospital officials. Three people are in serious condition with deep lacerations and orthopedic and internal injuries at Jersey…

    Good Morning America
  • 'Golden Girls' Action Figures Are Coming

    As it is every year, next week's New York Comic Con is famous for its exclusive products -- that is, toys and other items that you can only buy there. The four-day annual nerd mecca, which runs from Oct. 6 to Oct. 9 at the Jacob K. Javits Center in Manhattan, will be the only place to buy the…

    Good Morning America
  • Video Showing Police Shooting of Louisiana Boy Released

    Nearly a year after two law enforcement officers opened fire on a car in Louisiana, killing an autistic boy and wounding his father, the state judge presiding over the cases has ordered the release of the footage from the body camera that captured the tragic incident. The shooting happened during…

    Good Morning America
  • Luke Bryan Talks Raising His Orphaned Nephew: 'We Love It'

    In an interview with People, the singer opened up about raising his 14-year-old nephew, Til, whom he and his wife took in after the death of Bryan's brother-in-law in 2014. The singer's sister, Til's mother, died in 2007. In addition to raising Til, Bryan, 40, and his wife Caroline have two sons,…

    Good Morning America