Is That Brand Name Makeup You Bought Online a Knockoff?

ABC News Blogs

ABC News Videos

Online Beauty Bargains: Is It the Real Deal?

Online Beauty Bargains: Is It the Real Deal?

Online Beauty Bargains: Is It the Real Deal?

Now watching

Next video starts in : 7 Play

Online Beauty Bargains: Is It the Real Deal?

ABC News' Becky Worley reports:

Looking for an online deal on brand name makeup? Be careful: the world of knockoffs isn't just about purses; makeup that claims to be something it's really not can be found all over the Internet.

Paying 25 dollars for face powder or mascara hurts, but buying a knockoff could hurt more. I ordered brand name mascara, foundation, lipstick, and pore minimizer from third-party vendors off of eBay, Amazon and some online makeup "outlets" to see if any might be knockoffs.

A few observations about buying discount makeup online:

1) I noticed that the discount items I ordered weren't that much cheaper. For example the Benefit Mascara was about $6 less than the retail cost

2) The sellers I purchased from on eBay all had multiple lots of items; they seemed like businesses, not individuals.

3) On Amazon, all the items sold at a discount were from third-party sellers.

4) At supposed "outlet" stores, the items were much much cheaper than retail, but the shipping was a flat rate of $40.

As the products started rolling in, the first package arrived from China. The waybill on my MAC makeup package showed the originating city as Beijing. When I opened it up, the foundation and lipstick looked like authentic products, but when I compared them to the same items I'd purchased in the MAC store, there were obvious defects and graphics differences on the packaging. The mirror on the compact was chipped and the overall weight of the foundation seemed less.

Of all nine products I ordered online at Amazon and eBay, four seemed suspicious or certainly different in graphics and looks from the authentic products: the Benefit mascara & pore minimizer and MAC foundation and lipstick.

We sent the Benefit mascara and the MAC foundation to the labs of the nonprofit health group NSF International to be tested. NSF found the Benefit Mascara was not comparable to the one purchased at an authorized retailer- the packaging and chemical formulations weren't the same. NSF said the chemical differences were just slight and not of concern .

The more staggering result was the MAC foundation we bought from a third party vendor outlet site. NSF said it contained 260 micrograms of lead per gram compared to the authentic version's 0.27 micrograms per gram- that's nearly 1,000 times as much!

Dermatologist Dr. Gloria Graf says depending on the contents of these knockoff makeup products, there is a risk "they can permanently scar you if you get a reaction on your skin that is severe enough".

So how do you spot a knockoff online?

*The prices on brand-name makeup products are highly regulated by the manufacturer. If the deal is too good to be true, there's probably something wrong.

*If you aren't sure about a product, search "how to spot a fake (name of the product)." A cadre of beauty bloggers have posted very helpful write-ups and pictures detailing the graphics mistakes and discrepancies that they say indicate you may have a knockoff.

*Don't depend on the picture online to tell you if it's a knockoff. It's possible that you will see photos of the real product online, but what arrives at your doorstep could end up a graphically different knockoff.

*If a website doesn't accept a credit card on their own site with an HTTPS or if they use a third party payment service (if it redirects you to a different website to take your credit card), be wary. It may mean previous purchasers contested their charges with the credit companies and those vendors have been black-listed.

*Knockoffs purchased online are often sold in big lots. Those can in turn be sold at flea markets or mall kiosks. The knockoffs could be out in the physical world too.

*If the product's consistency or texture just doesn't feel or look like the authentic brand, don't use it.

*Both eBay and Amazon told us they work hard to prevent the sale of knockoff goods on their sites, and investigate any user reports of them and take appropriate actions. eBay even told us they "restricted the account in question" after we reported our experience to them.

*MAC and Benefit told us that the only way to ensure the quality of their products is to buy them from an authorized retailer.

View Comments (8)

Recommended for You

  • Beyonce Turns 34: 34 Reasons to Celebrate the Music Icon

    9/4/81.Bey day.Today is Beyoncé’s birthday and unsurprisingly, the singer’s fans (known as the Bey-hive) have been out in full force.#HappyBirthdayBeyonce trended on Twitter all morning and in the afternoon, #BeyDay began to trend as well. So in honor of Queen Bey’s 34th birthday, here are 34…

    Good Morning America21 mins ago
  • 'Star Wars' Universe Introduces First Major Gay Hero

    In the new novel, "Star Wars: Aftermath," we meet the first major gay character: Imperial traitor and new member of the rebellion, Sinjir Rath Velus. Velus is not the first gay character, but the first gay major hero, Entertainment Weekly reports. But Velus has now sided with the rebels and the…

    Good Morning America57 mins ago
  • Eric Decker and Jessie James Decker Welcome a Son

    Eric Decker and Jesse James Decker are now parents of two. Decker, 28, and James Decker, 27, announced in March that they were expecting a second child. "Vivianne is so excited because she is going to be a big sister!" James Decker wrote on Instagram at the time.

    Good Morning America57 mins ago
  • Pope Francis to Texas Nun Norma Pimentel: 'I Love You All Very Much'

    When Sister Norma Pimentel participated in a virtual papal audience hosted by ABC News this week, she was excited to see Pope Francis, but never expected him to address her directly. Sister Pimentel runs a welcome center at Sacred Heart Church in McAllen, Texas, which has helped more than 20,000…

    Good Morning America
  • Jailed Kentucky Clerk Kim Davis Offers 'Remedy' in Same-Sex Marriage License Battle

    The Kentucky county clerk, jailed for failing to follow a judge’s orders to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples, wants her name removed from the marriage certificates, her attorney Matthew Staver told ABC News. “She has a very strong conscience and she’s just asking for a simple remedy,…

    Good Morning America
  • Garbage Bins Mysteriously Turn Into Minions Overnight, and Locals Celebrate the 'Binions'

    Garbage bins in East Sussex, U.K., recently turned into Minions, and residents have been abuzz trying to figure who painted them, according to the local newspaper. The cheeky, yellow cartoon characters appeared overnight this past Monday in the small southern U.K. towns of Peacehaven, Newhaven and…

    Good Morning America
  • Artist's Hand-Painted Wedding Shoes Create a Truly Magical Walk Down the Aisle

    One woman is single-handedly transforming the way brides walk down the aisle.Deborah Thomson is not only a wedding photographer, she also channels her creativity into shoes. Beautiful, intricate, hand-painted wedding shoes, specifically.What all began as a last-minute request from a fellow…

    Good Morning America
  • Family Alleges Pest Fumigation Left Boy Severely Injured

    The family of a 10-year-old boy said he had to be rushed to the hospital where he has remained for weeks after being exposed to fumigation chemicals in their house. The family of Peyton McCaughey said that after their home in Palm City, Florida, was fumigated in August, multiple family members…

    Good Morning America
  • Walmart Apologizes to Iowa Mom for Refusing to Print Breast-Feeding Photos

    Walmart has apologized to an Iowa mom for refusing to print photos of her breast-feeding her children. "I was furious and I was also embarrassed," Whitney Walters of Knoxville, Iowa, told ABC News today. Walters, a mother of five, said she placed an order two weeks ago to have pictures of her…

    Good Morning America
  • Meet the 1st Same-Sex Couple to Get Marriage License in Rowan County, Ky

    James Yates and William Smith Jr. were the first same-sex couple to receive a marriage license in Rowan County, Kentucky, this morning, while clerk Kim Davis remains in jail for failing to follow a judge’s orders to issue the licenses. Smith and Yates, of Morehead, Kentucky, have been together for…

    Good Morning America
  • Why 'The Transporter Refueled' Is an Unnecessary Retread

    Having said that, "The Transporter Refueled" isn’t bad. A high-priced prostitute named Anna (Loan Chabanol) has devised a plan to rip off her brutal Russian mobster pimp, and hires Frank Martin, a.k.a. "The Transporter," to help.

    Good Morning America
  • Pink Speaks Out About Perceived Feud With Demi Lovato

    Pink found herself in a Twitter feud with Demi Lovato fans Friday.In a post on her private Instagram page, which has been shared by several outlets, the "Raise Your Glass" singer wrote that the MTV Video Music Awards made her sad because "this trash won't save any kids life."Lovato, 23, who…

    Good Morning America
  • Tori Spelling Suing Benihana Restaurants Over Alleged Slip-and-Fall Grill Burn

    Actress Tori Spelling is suing Benihana restaurants, alleging that she was badly burned after slipping and falling on a hot grill at one of the hibachi chain’s locations in California. In court papers filed in Los Angeles County Superior Court on Wednesday, the 42-year-old “Beverly Hills: 90210”…

    Good Morning America
  • Giant Straw Dinosaurs Amaze Visitors at Wara Art Festival in Japan

    Visitors to the recent Wara Art Festival in Niigata, Japan, were left in awe by the giant sculptures of dinosaurs -- up to 16 feet tall -- only made out of straw, according to the festival's official website.The festival was started eight years ago as a way to celebrate the end of the rice harvest…

    Good Morning America
  • Ebay Seller Who Sued Over Negative Feedback Ordered to Pay Customers' Legal Fees

    An eBay seller who sued two customers over their negative feedback online has been ordered to pay $19,250 to cover their legal fees. This week, a judge ordered Med Express Inc., a refurbished medical equipment seller who sued back in 2013, to pay for the two Ohio lawyers who defended the case pro…

    Good Morning America
  • Where 3-Year-Old Girl in Iconic Katrina Photo is Now 10 Years After Rescue

    The three-year-old girl in this iconic photograph from Hurricane Katrina, showing her bear-hugging the airman who rescued her, still has the same big smile 10 years later.LeShay Brown, now 13, has finally been reconnected with Air Force Master Sgt. Mike Michael Maroney, who had been searching for…

    Good Morning America
  • Deflategate: Bridget Moynahan Tweets Congrats to Tom Brady After Ruling

    Shortly after a federal judge overruled Tom Brady's four-game suspension Thursday, his ex took to social media to share her "congrats" for the father of her child. Brady, 38, and the actress, 44, dated from 2004 to 2006 and in late 2007, the former couple welcomed a baby boy John. Brady married…

    Good Morning America