Exclusive: Benghazi Talking Points Underwent 12 Revisions, Scrubbed of Terror Reference

White House Benghazi Attack Talking Points Edited

Now watching

Next video starts in : 7 Play

White House Benghazi Attack Talking Points Edited

White House Benghazi Attack Talking Points Edited
Replay video
Up next

Grateful Dead's "Rainbowgate" Cleared Up, Was Not Man-Made

Grateful Dead's "Rainbowgate" Cleared Up, Was Not Man-Made Up next

Grateful Dead's "Rainbowgate" Cleared Up, Was Not Man-Made

When it became clear last fall that the CIA's now discredited Benghazi talking points were flawed, the White House said repeatedly the documents were put together almost entirely by the intelligence community, but White House documents reviewed by Congress suggest a different story.

ABC News has obtained 12 different versions of the talking points that show they were extensively edited as they evolved from the drafts first written entirely by the CIA to the final version distributed to Congress and to U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. Susan Rice before she appeared on five talk shows the Sunday after that attack.

Related: Read the Full Benghazi Talking Point Revisions

White House emails reviewed by ABC News suggest the edits were made with extensive input from the State Department. The edits included requests from the State Department that references to the Al Qaeda-affiliated group Ansar al-Sharia be deleted as well references to CIA warnings about terrorist threats in Benghazi in the months preceding the attack.

That would appear to directly contradict what White House Press Secretary Jay Carney said about the talking points in November.

"Those talking points originated from the intelligence community. They reflect the IC's best assessments of what they thought had happened," Carney told reporters at the White House press briefing on November 28, 2012. "The White House and the State Department have made clear that the single adjustment that was made to those talking points by either of those two institutions were changing the word 'consulate' to 'diplomatic facility' because 'consulate' was inaccurate."

Summaries of White House and State Department emails - some of which were first published by Stephen Hayes of the Weekly Standard - show that the State Department had extensive input into the editing of the talking points.

State Department spokesman Victoria Nuland raised specific objections to this paragraph drafted by the CIA in its earlier versions of the talking points:

"The Agency has produced numerous pieces on the threat of extremists linked to al-Qa'ida in Benghazi and eastern Libya. These noted that, since April, there have been at least five other attacks against foreign interests in Benghazi by unidentified assailants, including the June attack against the British Ambassador's convoy. We cannot rule out the individuals has previously surveilled the U.S. facilities, also contributing to the efficacy of the attacks."

In an email to officials at the White House and the intelligence agencies, State Department spokesman Victoria Nuland took issue with including that information because it "could be abused by members [of Congress] to beat up the State Department for not paying attention to warnings, so why would we want to feed that either? Concerned …"

The paragraph was entirely deleted.

Like the final version used by Ambassador Rice on the Sunday shows, the CIA's first drafts said the attack appeared to have been "spontaneously inspired by the protests at the U.S. Embassy in Cairo" but the CIA version went on to say, "That being said, we do know that Islamic extremists with ties to al-Qa'ida participated in the attack." The draft went on to specifically name the al Qaeda-affiliated group named Ansar al-Sharia.

Once again, Nuland objected to naming the terrorist groups because "we don't want to prejudice the investigation."

In response, an NSC staffer coordinating the review of the talking points wrote back to Nuland, "The FBI did not have major concerns with the points and offered only a couple minor suggestions."

After the talking points were edited slightly to address Nuland's concerns, she responded that changes did not go far enough.

"These changes don't resolve all of my issues or those of my buildings leadership," Nuland wrote.

In an email dated 9/14/12 at 9:34 p.m. - three days after the attack and two days before Ambassador Rice appeared on the Sunday shows - Deputy National Security Advisor Ben Rhodes wrote an email saying the State Department's concerns needed to be addressed.

"We must make sure that the talking points reflect all agency equities, including those of the State Department, and we don't want to undermine the FBI investigation. We thus will work through the talking points tomorrow morning at the Deputies Committee meeting."

Related: Diplomat Says Requests For Benghazi Rescue Were Rejected

After that meeting, which took place Saturday morning at the White House, the CIA drafted the final version of the talking points - deleting all references to al Qaeda and to the security warnings in Benghazi prior to the attack.

White House Press Secretary Jay Carney said none of this contradicts what he said about the talking points because ultimately all versions were actually written and signed-off by the CIA.

"The CIA drafted these talking points and redrafted these talking points," Carney said. "The fact that there are inputs is always the case in a process like this, but the only edits made by anyone here at the White House were stylistic and nonsubstantive. They corrected the description of the building or the facility in Benghazi from consulate to diplomatic facility and the like. And ultimately, this all has been discussed and reviewed and provided in enormous levels of detail by the administration to Congressional investigators, and the attempt to politicize the talking points, again, is part of an effort to, you know, chase after what isn't the substance here."

UPDATE: A source familiar with the White House emails on the Benghazi talking point revisions say that State Department spokesman Victoria Nuland was raising two concerns about the CIA's first version of talking points, which were going to be sent to Congress: 1) The talking points went further than what she was allowed to say about the attack during her state department briefings; and, 2) she believed the CIA was attempting to exonerate itself at the State Department's expense by suggesting CIA warnings about the security situation were ignored.

In one email, Nuland asked, why are we suggest Congress "start making assertions to the media [about the al Qaeda connection] that we ourselves are not making because we don't want to prejudice the investigation?"

One other point: The significant edits - deleting references to al Qaeda and the CIA's warnings - came after a White House meeting on the Saturday before Ambassador Susan Rice appeared on five Sunday shows. Nuland, a 30-year foreign service veteran who has served under Democratic and Republican Secretaries of State, was not at that meeting and played no direct role in preparing Rice for her interviews.

View Comments (10010)

Recommended for You

  • Watch Alex Trebek Rap the 'Fresh Prince' Theme Song

    Will Smith would be proud. During a question about TV theme songs, Jeopardy host Alex Trebek took to rapping the "Fresh Prince of Bel-Air" jingle.Trebek got really into the jam and even altered his voice to sound more hip-hop. Calling this epic would be the understatement of the century.Read:…

    Good Morning America25 mins ago
  • Ben Affleck and Jennifer Garner to Divorce

    Garner, 43, and Affleck, 42, married in 2005 and have three children, Violet, 9, Seraphina, 6, and Samuel, 3. Years later, Affleck admitted that he fell in love with Garner on the set of the film. They got engaged in April 2005 and married two months later in a private ceremony in the Turks and…

    Good Morning America28 mins ago
  • Taylor Swift Gives Fans Free Tickets After Flight Delay Makes Them Miss London Show

    When two South African Swifties missed her concert at London’s Hyde Park after their flight was delayed, the "Style" singer offered them free tickets to her Dublin show. Stephanie Be and her boyfriend Joe Crann only managed to catch the last three songs of Saturday's show thanks to the travel…

    Good Morning America30 mins ago
  • Texas Man Builds Miniature House in Hopes of Avoiding College Debt

    Joel Weber said he's determined to incur less college debt by living in the tiny, 145-square-foot house he built, rather than struggling to pay higher rent in his college town of Austin, Texas. Weber, who will begin his junior year at the University of Texas at Austin, said it can cost upwards of…

    Good Morning America38 mins ago
  • Girl Scouts Return $100K After Donor Requests It Not Be Used to Support Transgender Girls

    The Girl Scouts of Western Washington recently returned $100,000 to a donor who sent a follow-up note to the donation requesting that the gift "not be used to support transgender girls," the group said. Despite the loss, the Girl Scouts have now raised the amount back, and some more, in less than…

    Good Morning America42 mins ago
  • Princess Charlotte's Christening: Mario Testino Picked as Photographer

    The Duchess of Cambridge famously snapped the first photos released of her son and newborn daughter together, but the royal family has tapped a world-renowned photographer to record their next milestone. Mario Testino, who has photographed generations of Britain’s royal family, will take the…

    Good Morning America52 mins ago
  • Arizona 10-Year-Old, Formerly Homeless, to Make Clothes for Kids Less Fortunate

    Stephanie Elliot said she was completely taken by surprise when her son, Xavier Elliot, told her that he wanted to make clothes for homeless children, after learning what it was like to be homeless himself. "I think it affected him a lot," Elliot of Pheonix, Arizona told ABC News.

    Good Morning America55 mins ago
  • Woman Searches For Couple Who Got Engaged at Eiffel Tower

    A California woman captured the moment the pair got engaged at the Eiffel Tower -- and now she’s searching for the couple so she can share her photos with them. “If I was those people and I got engaged at sunset at the Eiffel Tower, I would want pictures of that moment,” Jenifer Bohn, of Clovis,…

    Good Morning America55 mins ago
  • Apple Music Launch: Hands on With Apple's New Streaming Service

    Apple is continuing to change the landscape of the music industry with its launch today of Apple Music, a streaming service offering members access to tens of millions of songs in the iTunes collection. While Apple is late to the music streaming game, it enters the market with one huge advantage:…

    Good Morning America55 mins ago
  • Amber Heard Opens Up About Being Bisexual and Marriage to Johnny Depp

    The "Magic Mike" actor, who tied the knot with the famed actor in February, has been acting since the mid-2000's and has several movies out this year including "The Danish Girl" opposite Oscar winner Eddie Redmayne. But before meeting Depp and eventually falling in love, the actress, 29, dated…

    Good Morning America
  • David Sweat Claims He Was Almost Caught Twice During 3-Week Manhunt

    Escaped prisoner David Sweat told investigators he was almost discovered twice during the three weeks authorities were searching the woods of upstate New York for him and fellow inmate Richard Matt -- including one time that police walked right by him as he hid in a hunting tree stand, officials…

    Good Morning America
  • NY Prison Escape: The Details David Sweat Told Investigators

    Escaped prisoner David Sweat, now in an upstate New York hospital, has allegedly revealed to investigators how he and fellow escapee Richard Matt managed to elude authorities in their three weeks on the run. Sweat told authorities he and Matt listened to reports about the manhunt on a radio, a…

    Good Morning America
  • Jeremy Renner Opens Up About Divorce and Sexual Preference Rumors

    Jeremy Renner is usually very quiet about his personal life, but did respond to rumors about his sexual preference and open up about his painful divorce in a recent interview with Playboy magazine. When you Google yourself and the first thing that comes up is 'Jeremy Renner gay,' it's like, 'Oh,…

    Good Morning America
  • Amy Schumer Explains Why She Turned Down 'The Daily Show'

    Amy Schumer was so flattered to be offered the position of "Daily Show" host that she cried. Schumer, 34, currently has her own Comedy Central show, "Inside Amy Schumer," and an upcoming film, "Trainwreck," that she wrote and stars in. Plus, she added, Trevor Noah, the comedian Comedy Central…

    Good Morning America
  • 2015 FIFA Women's World Cup: Complete Results

    The United States soccer team takes on top-ranked Germany tonight in the semifinals of the Women's World Cup at Montreal's Olympic Stadium -- putting it just one step away from Sunday's final. ...

    Good Morning America
  • Colony of Over 15,000 'Aggressive and Dangerous' Bees Takes Over Family's Home

    A neighborhood in southwest Houston, Texas, was abuzz after a colony of over 15,000 "aggressive and dangerous" bees recently terrorized a family just days after a separate swarm took over a vacant house across the street, according to a local exterminator. Jeff Stanifer of Bee Budget Removal in…

    Good Morning America
  • Superintendent Among 12 Clinton Correctional Facility Employees Placed on Leave

    Twelve Clinton Correctional Facility employees, including the superintendent, were placed on administrative leave as a part of the ongoing review into the escape of two inmates from its maximum security prison in Dannemora, New York. Three members of the Clinton Correctional Facility's Executive…

    Good Morning America