Exclusive: Benghazi Talking Points Underwent 12 Revisions, Scrubbed of Terror Reference

White House Benghazi Attack Talking Points Edited

Now watching

Next video starts in : 7 Play

White House Benghazi Attack Talking Points Edited

White House Benghazi Attack Talking Points Edited
Replay video
Up next

Community Episode 4: Queer Studies and Advanced Waxing

Community Episode 4: Queer Studies and Advanced Waxing Up next

Community Episode 4: Queer Studies and Advanced Waxing

When it became clear last fall that the CIA's now discredited Benghazi talking points were flawed, the White House said repeatedly the documents were put together almost entirely by the intelligence community, but White House documents reviewed by Congress suggest a different story.

ABC News has obtained 12 different versions of the talking points that show they were extensively edited as they evolved from the drafts first written entirely by the CIA to the final version distributed to Congress and to U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. Susan Rice before she appeared on five talk shows the Sunday after that attack.

Related: Read the Full Benghazi Talking Point Revisions

White House emails reviewed by ABC News suggest the edits were made with extensive input from the State Department. The edits included requests from the State Department that references to the Al Qaeda-affiliated group Ansar al-Sharia be deleted as well references to CIA warnings about terrorist threats in Benghazi in the months preceding the attack.

That would appear to directly contradict what White House Press Secretary Jay Carney said about the talking points in November.

"Those talking points originated from the intelligence community. They reflect the IC's best assessments of what they thought had happened," Carney told reporters at the White House press briefing on November 28, 2012. "The White House and the State Department have made clear that the single adjustment that was made to those talking points by either of those two institutions were changing the word 'consulate' to 'diplomatic facility' because 'consulate' was inaccurate."

Summaries of White House and State Department emails - some of which were first published by Stephen Hayes of the Weekly Standard - show that the State Department had extensive input into the editing of the talking points.

State Department spokesman Victoria Nuland raised specific objections to this paragraph drafted by the CIA in its earlier versions of the talking points:

"The Agency has produced numerous pieces on the threat of extremists linked to al-Qa'ida in Benghazi and eastern Libya. These noted that, since April, there have been at least five other attacks against foreign interests in Benghazi by unidentified assailants, including the June attack against the British Ambassador's convoy. We cannot rule out the individuals has previously surveilled the U.S. facilities, also contributing to the efficacy of the attacks."

In an email to officials at the White House and the intelligence agencies, State Department spokesman Victoria Nuland took issue with including that information because it "could be abused by members [of Congress] to beat up the State Department for not paying attention to warnings, so why would we want to feed that either? Concerned …"

The paragraph was entirely deleted.

Like the final version used by Ambassador Rice on the Sunday shows, the CIA's first drafts said the attack appeared to have been "spontaneously inspired by the protests at the U.S. Embassy in Cairo" but the CIA version went on to say, "That being said, we do know that Islamic extremists with ties to al-Qa'ida participated in the attack." The draft went on to specifically name the al Qaeda-affiliated group named Ansar al-Sharia.

Once again, Nuland objected to naming the terrorist groups because "we don't want to prejudice the investigation."

In response, an NSC staffer coordinating the review of the talking points wrote back to Nuland, "The FBI did not have major concerns with the points and offered only a couple minor suggestions."

After the talking points were edited slightly to address Nuland's concerns, she responded that changes did not go far enough.

"These changes don't resolve all of my issues or those of my buildings leadership," Nuland wrote.

In an email dated 9/14/12 at 9:34 p.m. - three days after the attack and two days before Ambassador Rice appeared on the Sunday shows - Deputy National Security Advisor Ben Rhodes wrote an email saying the State Department's concerns needed to be addressed.

"We must make sure that the talking points reflect all agency equities, including those of the State Department, and we don't want to undermine the FBI investigation. We thus will work through the talking points tomorrow morning at the Deputies Committee meeting."

Related: Diplomat Says Requests For Benghazi Rescue Were Rejected

After that meeting, which took place Saturday morning at the White House, the CIA drafted the final version of the talking points - deleting all references to al Qaeda and to the security warnings in Benghazi prior to the attack.

White House Press Secretary Jay Carney said none of this contradicts what he said about the talking points because ultimately all versions were actually written and signed-off by the CIA.

"The CIA drafted these talking points and redrafted these talking points," Carney said. "The fact that there are inputs is always the case in a process like this, but the only edits made by anyone here at the White House were stylistic and nonsubstantive. They corrected the description of the building or the facility in Benghazi from consulate to diplomatic facility and the like. And ultimately, this all has been discussed and reviewed and provided in enormous levels of detail by the administration to Congressional investigators, and the attempt to politicize the talking points, again, is part of an effort to, you know, chase after what isn't the substance here."

UPDATE: A source familiar with the White House emails on the Benghazi talking point revisions say that State Department spokesman Victoria Nuland was raising two concerns about the CIA's first version of talking points, which were going to be sent to Congress: 1) The talking points went further than what she was allowed to say about the attack during her state department briefings; and, 2) she believed the CIA was attempting to exonerate itself at the State Department's expense by suggesting CIA warnings about the security situation were ignored.

In one email, Nuland asked, why are we suggest Congress "start making assertions to the media [about the al Qaeda connection] that we ourselves are not making because we don't want to prejudice the investigation?"

One other point: The significant edits - deleting references to al Qaeda and the CIA's warnings - came after a White House meeting on the Saturday before Ambassador Susan Rice appeared on five Sunday shows. Nuland, a 30-year foreign service veteran who has served under Democratic and Republican Secretaries of State, was not at that meeting and played no direct role in preparing Rice for her interviews.

View Comments (10033)

Recommended for You

  • Avril Lavigne and Lyme Disease: Your Questions Answered

    Lyme disease is caused by the bacterium borrelia burgdorferi and transmitted to humans through the bite of infected blacklegged ticks, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. By agency estimates, Lavigne is one of 30,000 Americans diagnosed with Lyme disease each year. Dr.…

    Good Morning America12 mins ago
  • Kate Hudson Says She and Her Ex Are 'Family for the Rest of Our Lives'

    Kate Hudson and Matt Bellamy still seem to be on good terms after splitting last year. In fact, the two are still the co-owners of Hudson Bellamy Wines. The two, who ended their engagement last December after a four-year romance, have a 3-year-old son, Bingham Hawn Bellamy.

    Good Morning America13 mins ago
  • All the Best Food Company April Fools' Day Pranks

    Watch your back today, people. It's April 1 and hard to tell what’s real and what’s not.Not one to miss a fun opportunity, food companies are celebrating April Fools’ Day with a variety of pranks that really are just too good to be true. Here’s a look at the best.Foodie Fun For April Fools’…

    Good Morning America28 mins ago
  • 7 April Fool's Day Jokes That Show Techies Have a Sense of Humor

    "Today we’re excited to introduce Smartbox—a better, smarter mailbox that fuses physical mail with everything you love about the electronic kind," Google wrote in a blog post. We've dropped the resolution, and in doing so re-discovered our roots," design lead Daniel Glass said.

    Good Morning America35 mins ago
  • Joe Giudice Opens Up About Teresa's Life in Prison

    "Real Housewives of New Jersey" star Joe Giudice is opening up about life without his wife Teresa, who is serving a 15-month prison sentence at Danbury Federal Prison. Giudice spoke to "Extra" and said his four daughters -- Gia, 13, Milania 9, Gabriella, 8, and Audriana, 3 -- keep in touch with…

    Good Morning America36 mins ago
  • 12-Year-Old Called 911 After Intruder Broke Into His Home

    A 12-year-old Massachusetts boy home sick from school called 911 after an intruder broke into his family’s home -- and with a dispatcher’s help, contributed to police making an arrest. Luke Fournier of Waltham, Massachusetts, was home last Friday when he spotted a stranger at the door. Fournier…

    Good Morning America44 mins ago
  • Jamie Dornan Once Stalked Woman on Train for a Role

    Jamie Dornan might be known for his leading role in "Fifty Shades of Grey," but the 32-year-old actor gets even more intense playing a serial killer on the Netflix show "The Fall."In fact, he went so dark one night that he stalked a woman on the train, in efforts to get into his character's…

    Good Morning America55 mins ago
  • Cynthia Lennon: John Lennon's First Wife Dies at 75

    John Lennon's first wife Cynthia Lennon died today at her home in Spain. As stated in the announcement, Cynthia and John had one child together -- Julian, 51. "He's made his mistakes, on the front pages of newspapers, all over the world," Cynthia Lennon said. Cynthia Lennon was married three…

    Good Morning America59 mins ago
  • Artist Recreates da Vinci's 'The Last Supper' Using French Fries, Ketchup

    A visual artist from Atlanta who's worked with big stars like Usher and Whitney Houston now wants to use his talent to spotlight more unprivileged people -- those suffering from hunger.Using french fries as brushes and ketchup as paint, Mil Cannon recreated Leonardo da Vinci's "The Last Supper."A…

    Good Morning America
  • Giuliana Rancic Explains Why She's so Thin

    During awards season earlier this year, many in Hollywood noticed Giuliana Rancic's thin figure. The "Fashion Police" co-host said she agrees that she's slim, but added that it's not for the reasons that have been bandied about in the media. "Some people were saying, 'The cancer is probably…

    Good Morning America
  • David Spade Remembers the 'Late Great Chris Farley' on 20th Anniversary of 'Tommy Boy'

    "I'm told that today is the 20th anniversary of Tommyboy," he wrote. "Aside from that making me older than f--- I have to say thanks to everyone who has said nice things to me over the years.

    Good Morning America
  • Germanwings Crash: Video May Show Plane's Final Moments

    Two magazines have reported details of a disturbing video taken from inside the doomed Germanwings plane moments before it crashed into the French Alps, but investigators have denied its existence. While ABC News has not independently confirmed the existence of the video, the editor of Parisian…

    Good Morning America
  • Total Lunar Eclipse Will Be Shortest in a Century

    Don't press the snooze button for this one.The total lunar eclipse set to take over the skies on Saturday will be the shortest in a century, lasting five minutes and turning the moon red, according to NASA.Solar Eclipse 2015: What It Looked Like From SpaceEclipse 2015: Astonishing Images From…

    Good Morning America
  • The Pet Rock Captured a Moment and Made Its Creator a Millionaire

    Gary Ross Dahl devised the perfect pet. Dahl’s Pet Rock was a key innovation of the 1970s, tongue-in-cheek humor for a post-Watergate world, a pop culture fad that made its creator lots of money -- and continued to draw bemused attention in the decades that followed. Dahl, whose death was…

    Good Morning America
  • Avril Lavigne Reveals She Has Lyme Disease

    Rocker Avril Lavigne has revealed the health crisis she hinted to fans about last year on social media -- it's Lyme disease. “She has rarely left her home,” said People staff writer Patrick Gomez.

    Good Morning America
  • What's New on iTunes, Netflix and Hulu for April

    This is no April Fools' joke -- there's a lot to watch on iTunes, Netflix and Hulu for the month. There's hours and hours to watch on these streaming services.Whether it's movies such as the acclaimed "American Sniper" or new shows including Marvel's "Daredevil," many people are going to be glued…

    Good Morning America
  • Netanyahu Slams Iran Nuclear Talks, Calls for 'Better Deal'

    Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stepped up his opposition to the ongoing nuclear talks between Iran, the United States and its European allies, saying it was "time for the international community to insist on a better deal.""A better deal would significantly roll back Iran's nuclear…

    Good Morning America