'Girls' Episode Sparks Beauty Debate

ABC News Blogs

ABC News' Juju Chang reports:

Lena Dunham has taken Hollywood by storm as the town's unlikely "It" girl, creating and starring in the HBO sitcom "Girls."

Now Dunham, 25, who, along with her character "Hannah," has been said to be the voice of the 20-something generation, is once again smack dab in the middle of a culture war.

Much has been blogged about the fact that Dunham is not conventionally beautiful, so when her TV character hooked up with the actor Patrick Wilson, considered conventionally beautiful, onscreen, it launched a furious debate online about who is good enough for whom.

The affair between two seemingly mismatched mates - Wilson's character, Joshua, is an older, wealthy and very handsome doctor - has critics characterizing Wilson's character "as out of her [Hannah's] league" and calling the tryst between two different looking partners "implausible" and "uncomfortable."

"At the end of the day, it's very unkind but it's also human nature," Jennifer Heller, a New York City-based professional matchmaker, told ABC News.

The show, which recently won two Golden Globes for best comedy series and for best comedy actress, is the second incident in recent weeks in which a mismatched pair has sparked outrage.

A Super Bowl commercial from Go Daddy, which registers Internet domain names, succeeded in grabbing attention when it showed supermodel Bar Refaeli giving a lengthy, sloppy kiss to a non-supermodel partner, actor Jesse Heiman, who pulled off the look of a geek in the ad.

"I've been with Go Daddy for years and have endured the horrific ads you've featured the past several years," one customer wrote on Go Daddy's customer support message board. "It seems each time you are going for shock value, and [are] hoping the buzz about it somehow converts to actual sales. However, last night's ad was the final straw for me. …"

While some assume the mismatch is made up by money, power or social status, matchmaker Heller says the attraction between two unlikely pairs can be real.

"People have emotional needs. It's not just about the physical," she said. "Their need is being filled by this person."

View Comments (-3)

Recommended for You

  • What's New on Netflix and iTunes for May

    It's May 1 and that means a whole new slate of movies and TV on Netflix and iTunes. Fun hits like "Kung Fu Panda 3" and classics like "Bring It On" are coming to the respective streaming services. ...

    Good Morning America
  • 7 Beautiful Spots in Nature That Will Make You Feel Small

    Whether beautiful, daunting, dangerous, or just plain mind-blowing, the natural surroundings of these seven hotels will make you feel totally insignificant -- in a super-inspiring way. Located in the foothills of the Sangre de Cristo Mountains, the Four Seasons Resort Rancho Encantado, is a…

    Good Morning America
  • Cheap Destinations for Summer

    Good news: There are deals for summer. Bad news: They’re not for everyone. Nevertheless, some cities are cheaper than others and we’ve got a list.We also have strategies that can help you get to almost any city for less, especially if you’re willing to endure a little inconvenience.Cheaper U.S.…

    Good Morning America
  • Bad and Good News for College Students

    The National Foundation for Credit Counseling contacted me with word that college student loan scams are rampant. Scammers often press you to act now or make a quick decision on a “special offer” or you might “lose out.” Legitimate student loans don’t have fast deadlines. This glimmer of good…

    Good Morning America
  • Sixth Death Confirmed in Texas Flooding, Including Woman and Her 4 Great Grandchildren

    Rising flood waters claimed the life of a sixth person in Palestine, Texas, local police confirmed Saturday evening. The mayor of Palestine, Bob Herrington, said in a statement, “The City of Palestine has suffered the worst flooding event in my 59 years of living here. A 64-year-old woman and her…

    Good Morning America
  • Ted Cruz Wins 10 of 13 Delegates at Virginia GOP Convention

    Ted Cruz won 10 of the 13 delegates up for grabs at the Virginia Republican Convention today, with Donald Trump taking the other three after state delegates voted in favor of the slate recommended by the nominations committee. The result had many Trump supporters upset, because Trump won the…

    Good Morning America
  • Official Hydroxycut Site

    Look Fit and Feel Great! Trust Hydroxycut For Results.

    HydroxycutSponsored
  • Missing North Carolina Mother and Daughter Hikers Found Safe in New Zealand Forest

    A mother and daughter from North Carolina who went missing Tuesday while hiking in New Zealand have been found, after reportedly spending days huddled together for warmth and rationing their supplies, local police said Saturday. Carolyn Lloyd, 45, and her daughter Rachel Lloyd, 22, were spotted in…

    Good Morning America
  • 'Harry Potter' Fan Spends Three Weeks Painting J.K. Rowling's Book Onto Wall in Fun DIY Project

    One Potterhead took her love for the "Harry Potter" franchise to a new level after she spent nearly a month painting the first page of J.K. Rowling's popular book series on a wall in her home. Young adult author Meredith McCardle recently moved into a new home in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, and…

    Good Morning America
  • #1 Dating Site for Singles 45+

    Don’t know how to meet singles near you? This is the place for you.

    SeniorPeopleMeet.comSponsored
  • Rob Kardashian Defends Proposing to Girlfriend in New 'Keeping Up With the Kardashians' Clip

    Rob Kardashian's proposal to his girlfriend Blac Chyna was a bit dramatic. In a new preview clip of "Keeping Up With the Kardashians," which returns to E! for its 12th season on Sunday night, the Kardashian clan's lone son defends his decision to propose to Blac Chyna, whose real name is Angela…

    Good Morning America
  • Nick Carter Shares First Photo of Newborn Son Odin Reign

    Nick Carter is on cloud nine thanks to his new (Backstreet) boy.On Friday, the singer shared the very first photo of his newborn son, Odin Reign Carter, with wife Lauren Kitt, on Instagram."I just love how peaceful he is. Daddy will be home soon Odin. #babies #love #family," he wrote as a caption…

    Good Morning America
  • 'Comedian-In-Chief' Obama to Deliver Final White House Correspondents Dinner Speech

    It's a comedy routine two presidential terms in the making, with Saturday marking the final time President Obama will don his "Comedian-In-Chief" hat to roast the press, politicians and celebrities at the annual White House Correspondents Dinner. Over the years, President Obama has used the dinner…

    Good Morning America
  • Scientology Leader’s Father Ron Miscavige Describes the Moment When He Says He Escaped

    Two hours east of Los Angeles, in Hemet, California, sits a 500-acre Scientology compound known as the “Gold Base.”The Church characterizes the base as a slice of Scientology utopia, with state-of-the-art facilities and gorgeous landscaping.“If you talk to the staff, they'll tell you it's a…

    Good Morning America
  • 9 Jaw-Dropping Views from 9 Beautiful Hotel Pools

    Flanked by private cabanas and lounge chairs, this 130-foot-long fresh-water, black-tiled pool directly faces the Pacific Ocean -- making for an incredible lounging spot. This hotel pool is about the the sights and the sounds.

    Good Morning America
  • Russian Fighter Flew a Barrel Roll Within 25 Feet of US Reconnaissance Plane Over Baltic Sea

    In another close encounter with Russian military aircraft over the Baltic Sea, the Pentagon said a Russian Su-27 fighter jet Friday conducted a barrel roll within 25 feet of a U.S. Air Force RC-135 reconnaissance plane flying in international airspace. It is the third time in as many weeks the…

    Good Morning America
  • Woman Reunited With Purse Allegedly Stolen 14 Years Ago

    Lisa Hall Mazzaglia of Amesbury said she was “stunned” to hear that police in Seabrook, New Hampshire, had her purse after it was found in the trash can of a Seabrook grocery store. "I found this confusing since my purse was sitting in my kitchen," Mazzaglia, a talent agent, told ABC News. …

    Good Morning America
  • Apple Will Analyze iPhone of Teen Missing at Sea

    Apple will analyze the recovered iPhone that may hold the key to what happened last summer when two Florida teens disappeared on a boating trip, according to an agreement reached by the teens' parents in court today. The recovered iPhone belonged to 14-year-old Austin Stephanos, who went missing…

    Good Morning America
  • Ariz. School Yanks Poster Some Students Find Offensive

    Officials removed a controversial poster from the Desert Ridge High School library in Mesa, Arizona, Thursday after some students took offense at its message that appears to be a humorous attempt to highlight the school’s dress code. “I don’t get offended easily, but this definitely crossed the…

    Good Morning America