Message-in-a-Bottle Proposal Goes Awry

ABC News Blogs

A true "happily ever after" moment went very awry for one Michigan couple. But don't worry, it has a happy ending.

Nathan Bluestein, 27, of North

View gallery


Courtesy Nathan Bluestein

ville, Mich. had every detail meticulously planned for his proposal to his girlfriend, May Gorial 32, of Madison Heights, Mich. He was going to take her boating. He had thought of everything. Except for the weather forecast.

"When we got up there it was warm. It didn't seem very windy. Seemed like a pretty normal day. I've never been on Lake Huron, and didn't know what to expect. I was just looking forward to getting out on the canoe and it was pretty exciting," Bluestein said in an interview with ABC News.

On Sept. 1, Bluestein and Gorial set out in a canoe in Michigan's Wild Fowl Bay for what Gorial thought was just a beautiful day for a boat ride. Little did she know that Bluestein had secretly packed a bottle containing a French poem, along with the introduction to his proposal, on paper he antiqued by dying it in tea and burning the edges.

Bluestein waited for an opportune moment when Gorial was distracted by a loud boat passing in the choppy waters, then tossed the bottle in the water.

"Just as we talked about turning around, this motor boat comes by. It was a small, older boat making a lot of noise, and she was distracted by it so I threw the bottle into the water about three to five feet away without her noticing," Bluestein said.

View gallery


Courtesy Nathan Bluestein

"I told her, 'Honey I think I just saw a message in a bottle. I think I saw paper in it. We're turning around anyways, let's go after it.'"

The couple began paddling to the bottle and Gorial was excited when she noticed there was, indeed, a note stuffed inside.

"She reaches in and she says, 'Honey, it is a message in a bottle.' So I open it, and the first page is this French poem I found, a really pretty poem. And May is a French teacher so I thought she'd appreciate it," Bluestein said.

As Gorial read the poem, she was translating it aloud to Bluestein, who continued to pretend he had no clue as to how they stumbled upon the bottle. But as she finished reading the first page, she asked Bluestein about the second page.

"My dearest May, you're my best friend and the love of my life and I can't imagine spending any moment without you. That being said…" she read as Bluestein got the ring ready to finish the line Gorial now knew was coming.

View gallery


Courtesy Nathan Bluestein

She finished the letter, looked up at him, and said, "Yes."

But meanwhile, strong winds had pulled them far offshore. And they hadn't noticed.

"Once the big-time excitement had toned down, we realized we were a pretty long way from where we needed to be. The waves had kicked up to three to five foot waves at this point. And we had to paddle back into them to get back. A half an hour later, we hadn't moved," said Bluestein.

The couple was growing tired from the paddling and Gorial was getting seasick. After trying by cellphone to call Gorial's father, who was staying in a nearby cabin, they were able to reach her brother.

"Her brother calls the sheriff's office and they're busy saving somebody else on the other side of the lake, so it would be a while. But I noticed about a mile away there's this island and the current was kind of pushing toward it, so I knew I had a little help getting us there," Bluestein said.

The pair finally reached the island, took refuge there, and successfully called for help.

"I finally get in touch with the sheriff's office so they could get my GPS signal. Unfortunately they had the GPS off by one number. They were searching on the other side of the island," Bluestein said. "An hour later, I still haven't seen them so they finally get me in touch with the person on the rescue boat."

So they waited as evening came. It was the perfect, most romantic time of day to be stuck alone together on an island.

"While we were on the island we got to see the sunset and the moon rise on the opposite side of the horizon. And it was a full moon, big and beautiful. Just as it was getting pitch dark and night was falling, they showed up."

The grateful couple hopped on the rescue boat, and as they approached the marina, fireworks were going off. It was like a scene straight out of a romance novel. It's now a running joke between them that Bluestein secretly planned the whole thing, catastrophe included.

Bluestein and Gorial were so grateful to the rescue team that they're planning to invite them to the wedding.

"Of course they're invited. They're our rescuers," Bluestein said.

Their wedding is tentatively scheduled for next April 6. It seems pretty clear this is one story they'll be sharing with the grandkids.

View Comments (186)

Recommended for You

  • NY Prison Escape: The Details David Sweat Told Investigators

    Escaped prisoner David Sweat, now in an upstate New York hospital, has allegedly revealed to investigators how he and fellow escapee Richard Matt managed to elude authorities in their three weeks on the run. Sweat told authorities he and Matt listened to reports about the manhunt on a radio, a…

    Good Morning America15 mins ago
  • Misty Copeland Is American Ballet Theatre's First Black Female Principal Dancer

    A fervent dream became reality today for ballerina Misty Copeland as she became the first black female principal dancer in the 75-year history of the American Ballet Theatre. "I'm just so honored, so extremely honored," Copeland said today during a news conference. "My dream has been ABT…

    Good Morning America15 mins ago
  • Superintendent Among 12 Clinton Correctional Facility Employees Placed on Leave

    Twelve Clinton Correctional Facility employees, including the superintendent, were placed on administrative leave as a part of the ongoing review into the escape of two inmates from its maximum security prison in Dannemora, New York. Three members of the Clinton Correctional Facility's Executive…

    Good Morning America15 mins ago
  • US Women's Soccer Team Beats Germany to Advance to World Cup Finals

    The US Women's National team defeated Germany Tuesday night to advance to the finals of the Women's World Cup. The Women's National Team took the lead in the 69th minute with a goal from Carli Lloyd after Germany racked up a yellow card. Annike Krahn took down Alex Morgan inside the box two…

    Good Morning America37 mins ago
  • 2015 FIFA Women's World Cup: Complete Results

    5 Storylines to Follow Ahead of US-Germany Semifinal5 Biggest Moments in US Soccer Team HistoryESPN: Complete Coverage of Canada 2015Group A:June 6Canada 1, China 0Netherlands 1, New Zealand 0June 11China 1, Netherlands 0Canada 0, New Zealand 0June 15Netherlands 1, Canada 1China 2, New Zealand…

    Good Morning America46 mins ago
  • Watermelon Thump Festival a Texas Tradition for 62 Years and Counting

    Most days of the year, Luling, Texas is a sleepy town of around 5,500 people. Come late June, though, that number swells to 35,000, and it’s all because of watermelon. Since 1954, Luling has been host to the Watermelon Thump, a four-day festival celebrating all things watermelon.

    Good Morning America
  • Donna Karan Steps Down as Chief Designer for DKNY

    Fashion designer Donna Karan has made a personal decision to step down as chief designer for Donna Karan New York (DKNY), the New York-based international fashion house announced today. Karan, who spent the last three decades revolutionizing "the working woman's wardrobe" for DKNY, will now be…

    Good Morning America
  • Ben Affleck and Jennifer Garner to Divorce

    Garner, 43, and Affleck, 42, married in 2005 and have three children, Violet, 9, Seraphina, 6, and Samuel, 3. Years later, Affleck admitted that he fell in love with Garner on the set of the film. They got engaged in April 2005 and married two months later in a private ceremony in the Turks and…

    Good Morning America
  • Amnesiac Woman Tries to Solve Mystery of Who She Is as She Battles Cancer

    Called "Sam," the woman was found in Southern California by firefighters in February and immediately taken to a local hospital, where she was diagnosed with ovarian cancer, according to a Facebook page created to help her find her family. Doctors told her a volleyball-sized ovarian tumor may have…

    Good Morning America
  • Watch Alex Trebek Rap the 'Fresh Prince' Theme Song

    Will Smith would be proud. During a question about TV theme songs, Jeopardy host Alex Trebek took to rapping the "Fresh Prince of Bel-Air" jingle.Trebek got really into the jam and even altered his voice to sound more hip-hop. Calling this epic would be the understatement of the century.Read:…

    Good Morning America
  • Taylor Swift Gives Fans Free Tickets After Flight Delay Makes Them Miss London Show

    When two South African Swifties missed her concert at London’s Hyde Park after their flight was delayed, the "Style" singer offered them free tickets to her Dublin show. Stephanie Be and her boyfriend Joe Crann only managed to catch the last three songs of Saturday's show thanks to the travel…

    Good Morning America
  • 'Ghostbusters' Director Paul Feig Tweets First Pictures From Set

    And we have our first look at the new costumes for the "Ghostbusters" reboot, starring Melissa McCarthy, Kristen Wiig, Leslie Jones and Kate McKinnon.Director Paul Feig tweeted out two pictures, one of the uniforms and the other of the beloved proton packs.Slideshow: Other Stars On SetRelated:…

    Good Morning America
  • Texas Man Builds Miniature House in Hopes of Avoiding College Debt

    Joel Weber said he's determined to incur less college debt by living in the tiny, 145-square-foot house he built, rather than struggling to pay higher rent in his college town of Austin, Texas. Weber, who will begin his junior year at the University of Texas at Austin, said it can cost upwards of…

    Good Morning America
  • Girl Scouts Return $100K After Donor Requests It Not Be Used to Support Transgender Girls

    The Girl Scouts of Western Washington recently returned $100,000 to a donor who sent a follow-up note to the donation requesting that the gift "not be used to support transgender girls," the group said. Despite the loss, the Girl Scouts have now raised the amount back, and some more, in less than…

    Good Morning America
  • Princess Charlotte's Christening: Mario Testino Picked as Photographer

    The Duchess of Cambridge famously snapped the first photos released of her son and newborn daughter together, but the royal family has tapped a world-renowned photographer to record their next milestone. Mario Testino, who has photographed generations of Britain’s royal family, will take the…

    Good Morning America
  • Leap Second: How Companies Are Preparing For Extra Second Today

    If today feels a bit longer, there's a reason for it.A leap second will be added to the clock to account for a discrepancy between Earth's rotation and the atomic clock.While there have been more than two dozen instances of a leap second being added since 1972, companies relying on their computer…

    Good Morning America
  • Arizona 10-Year-Old, Formerly Homeless, to Make Clothes for Kids Less Fortunate

    Stephanie Elliot said she was completely taken by surprise when her son, Xavier Elliot, told her that he wanted to make clothes for homeless children, after learning what it was like to be homeless himself. "I think it affected him a lot," Elliot of Pheonix, Arizona told ABC News.

    Good Morning America