Is SodaStream a Healthy Alternative to Soda? Avoid Syrups With Additives

ABC News Blogs

By DAVID ZINCZENKO

Soft drinks have been around since the 17 th century when lemonade vendors would walk around the streets of Paris, a tank of lemon juice sweetened with honey strapped to their backs. A hundred years later, in 1767, Dr. Joseph Priestley of England first figured out how to carbonate water, and soda pop was born. Let's just say things have gone downhill since then.

A 2012 Gallop Poll found that nearly half of all Americans drink soda daily. If you're a soda drinker, and resolved to cut calories in the New Year, then diet soda might seem like the best choice. But more and more, researchers are cautioning that the extreme sweetness of artificially sweetened sodas and the numerous chemicals in them may contribute to weight gain as much as the regular stuff.

What about SodaStream? The home soda brewing system has taken America by storm, reporting $436 million in sales in 2012, up 51 percent from the previous year according to published reports. With claims of being both environmentally- friendly as well providing soda that "fits your health and diet" (the nondiet versions use real sugar instead of high fructose corn syrup), is SodaStream a healthy alternative?

Well, just because SodaStream uses real sugar in the place of the commonly-used high-fructose corn syrup in their sodas, doesn't mean you're drinking something natural. The lower calorie totals in their regular flavored syrups don't come from the swap in sugars, but the addition of artificial sweetener sucralose. According to a company representative, sugar and Splenda are used in equal proportion in their non-diet drinks.

EXCERPT: 'Eat It to Beat It' by David Zinczenko, Plus Skirt Steak Recipe

Additionally, SodaStream's flavor packs still contain chemicals, just like regular sodas. Caramel coloring, used to make SodaStream's colas, is one of many additives that some consumers have gone out of their way to avoid based on animal studies that suggest possible cancer risks. And even healthy-sounding SodaStream flavors, such as diet pink grapefruit, can contain food dyes that have raised questions about some negative health issues, such as hyperactivity, in some children.

While high fructose corn syrup and sucralose are not necessarily worse for you than sugar, many nutritionists take issue with America's overconsumption of sugar and sweeteners in general, and point to a consumption of sugary drinks as a factor in the rising obesity rates and the prevalence of diabetes and heart disease.

But diehard soda lovers needn't give up their beloved pop just yet. SodaStream can still be a useful tool in your quest for better health. Just skip the sugar, dyes and artificial flavors and get creative. You can use it to build your own designer sodas: make seltzer with your SodaStream, then add in 100 percent pomegranate, cherry or cranberry juice. Companies such as P&H Soda Co., Drink More Good and even Williams-Sonoma carry lines of all-natural soda syrups, which can be used in lieu of the SodaStream brand syrups.

Or, you can take things into your own hands by creating your own flavors at home. Fresh ginger and simple syrup are all you need to make homemade ginger ale. There are even a number of cookbooks dedicated to homemade soda syrups available at your local library or bookstore.

While soda, in all shapes and forms, is basically sugar water, SodaStream can still be a worthy investment. For a truly healthy New Year, just swap the syrups with questionable additives for natural or homemade versions.

View photo

.
David Zinczenko is ABC News nutrition and wellness Editor and the author of "Eat It to Beat It!" To discover more hidden sources of sugar, and how to lose weight by skipping other ingredients in our everyday food, check out "Eat It to Beat It!" here .

FULL STATEMENT FROM SODASTREAM IN REGARDS TO 1/13 "GMA" SEGMENT:

The SodaStream system empowers consumers to make 'better for you' bubbles, personalized to each individual's taste. SodaStream's flavors do not contain high-fructose corn syrup or aspartame. All SodaStream flavors exceed the food safety standards set forth by the FDA, and are labeled in accordance with federal guidelines.

Specifically with regard to caramel coloring, any SodaStream products that contain caramel coloring do so at levels well under the warning threshold defined by the California Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986 (29 micrograms of 4-MEI per ready-to-drink serving).

Pertaining to artificial colors, dyes and other synthetic ingredients, SodaStream flavors use only those ingredients that are recognized as safe by the FDA. We encourage all consumers - especially those with sensitivity to particular ingredients - to read nutrition labels and make informed choices.

For those consumers seeking dye- and chemical-free options, SodaStream offers several flavor varieties made from natural ingredients that are completely free from artificially sourced flavors, colors and other synthetic ingredients.

View Comments (22)

Recommended for You

  • Stars Comment on Social Media Before Tonight's Presidential Debate

    Tonight's presidential debate between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump is must-see TV and many celebrities will be watching from home, as well as the front row.Billionaire entrepreneur and "Shark Tank" co-star Mark Cuban has already confirmed that he will be taking a front-row seat at the debate at…

    Good Morning America22 mins ago
  • Suspect Confesses in Washington Mall Shooting That Killed 5

    The suspect in last Friday's deadly mall shooting in Washington state that killed five people has confessed to police, according to charging documents. The alleged shooter -- Arcan Cetin, 20, of Oak Harbor, Washington -- was arrested Saturday after authorities received a tip that linked him to the…

    Good Morning America34 mins ago
  • Florida Woman Jumped on Purse-Snatcher's Car as He Tried to Get Away

    Surveillance video from a South Florida gas station caught the moment a woman jumped on top of a man's car after he allegedly stole her purse, according to the Broward Sheriff's Office (BSO). The incident happened on Sept. 17, while Janelle Della-Libera, 32, was pumping gas, according to the BSO…

    Good Morning America40 mins ago
  • To Fact-Check or Not: Campaigns Disagree on the Role of Debate Moderator

    The diverging views came after Fox News' Chris Wallace, who is moderating the third and final presidential debate, said it is not his job to judge the accuracy of the candidates' statements in real time. It's up to the other person to catch them on that," Wallace told Fox News earlier this month. …

    Good Morning America
  • Who Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump Invited to the First Presidential Debate

    While the biggest attraction during the presidential debate tonight will be the two candidates on stage, at least some attention will likely be paid to those in the audience. Hillary Clinton's campaign this morning released a partial list of guests invited by the Democratic presidential nominee to…

    Good Morning America
  • Anti-Vaxxer Mom Changes Mind After Her Three Kids Fall Ill

    Kristen O'Meara chose not to vaccinate her young daughters because she was a big believer in anti-vaccination research. That changed when all three were stricken with a case of rotavirus, which causes acute stomach distress. A teacher living outside Chicago, she added that she had "scoured…

    Good Morning America
  • Top 3 Expert Tips to Cozy Up Your Home This Fall

    Angela Boswell is the Senior Vice President of Design and Product Development for Ellery Homestyles, a supplier of branded and private label home-fashion products. "Second only to painting, changing your curtains is an easy way to update the look and style of your room," Boswell said.

    Good Morning America
  • Son Found After 8 Days Lost at Sea, Mother's Fate a Mystery

    The U.S. Coast Guard announced this afternoon that it has decided not to re-open a search for a 54-year-old Connecticut woman who disappeared after she and her son went on a fishing trip last week. Though her son, 22-year-old Nathan Carman, was found alive after eight days at sea, Linda Carman…

    Good Morning America
  • Cafeteria Manager Sheds 100 Pounds Eating Kids' Menu

    A nutrition manager at a Texas elementary school lost more than 100 pounds by simply eating the same foods she encouraged her students to consume for breakfast and lunch. McRae said she started eating breakfast and lunch from the cafeteria menu at Carver Elementary School in Baytown, Texas, every…

    Good Morning America
  • Iowa Mayor Asks Residents in Flood Evacuation Area to 'Please, Please Leave'

    Iowa residents are waiting nervously as the swollen Cedar River rises steadily to its highest levels since a devastating flood in 2008 that caused some $10 billion in damages and took one life. The river in Cedar Rapids is now 19.4 feet, a level at which major flooding can occur, officials said…

    Good Morning America
  • See How Amy Schumer Reacts to Mets Kiss Cam

    Amy Schumer is definitely a good sport. She was rooting for the New York Mets at Citi Field on Sunday with her boyfriend, Ben Hanisch, and father, Gordon Schumer, when the stadium's kiss cam zeroed in on the star. Schumer was more than willing to oblige.

    Good Morning America
  • Jada Pinkett Smith Posts Touching Tribute on Will's Birthday

    Happy birthdays all around!Will Smith turned 48 yesterday, and no one was prouder than the actor's wife, Jada Pinkett Smith.Pinkett Smith, who turned 45 last week, took to Facebook to post a poignant message.Read: Will Smith on Jared Leto's Role in 'Suicide Squad': 'He Went Full Joker'Related:…

    Good Morning America
  • 'Face-Off' Night Takes Over 'Dancing with the Stars'

    "Dancing with the Stars" is adding a new twist to the competition Monday night.For the first time, the ABC show is holding a "Face-Off" night. Two couples will face off by dancing the same style to different songs.Read: ‘DWTS’ 2016 Celebrity Cast Revealed: Ryan Lochte, Amber Rose, Rick Perry Among…

    Good Morning America
  • Gina Rodriguez on Playing Crew Member Andrea Fleytas in 'Deepwater Horizon'

    Gina Rodriguez is starring in the highly anticipated drama "Deepwater Horizon."The actress plays crew member Andrea Fleytas, who survived the explosion that occurred on an oil rig in the Gulf of Mexico on April 20, 2010.Mark Wahlberg Reveals Scariest Part of Filming 'Deepwater Horizon'First Look at…

    Good Morning America
  • 60,000 Residents of Besieged Syrian Towns Get Aid for First Time Since April

    Long-awaited aid has reached Madaya and three other besieged Syrian towns for the first time since April. Humanitarian assistance was supposed to arrive in Madaya, Foah, Zabadani and Kefraya last Tuesday, but that delivery was put on temporary hold following an attack on an aid convoy in western…

    Good Morning America
  • 'The Magnificent Seven' Tops the Weekend Box Office

    "The Magnificent Seven" was the top draw at the box office over the weekend.The remake of the 1960 Western, starring Denzel Washington and Chris Pratt among others, debuted in first place by earning an estimated $35 million.The film was directed by Antoine Fuqua, who previously directed Washington…

    Good Morning America
  • Ronan Farrow Remembers His Late Brother Thaddeus After His Suicide

    Ronan Farrow, the son of actress Mia Farrow and director Woody Allen, took to social media on Sunday to remember his late brother, Thaddeus. Thaddeus, Mia Farrow's adopted son, was found dead in his car Wednesday in Roxbury, Connecticut. On Sunday, Ronan Farrow, 28, shared two childhood photos of…

    Good Morning America