New York Man Summoned to Court for Laughing Too Loud

Man Faces Jail Time for Laughing Too Loud

Now watching

Next video starts in : 7 Play

Man Faces Jail Time for Laughing Too Loud

Man Faces Jail Time for Laughing Too Loud
Replay video
Up next

Celebrities With Insured Body Parts

Celebrities With Insured Body Parts Up next

Celebrities With Insured Body Parts

Robert Schiavelli of Rockville Center, N.Y., says he never thought laughing could get him in trouble with the law.

"I was laughing out the window. I was laughing out the window of my own house, and they gave me a ticket," Schiavelli told ABC News.

Schiavelli was slapped with two summonses for disturbing the peace after police said he was laughing too loudly in his front yard.

Police responded to Schiavelli's home Feb. 12 and Feb. 13 after neighbors complained that his laughs could be heard across the driveway.

Schiavelli, who is considered disabled because of neurological impairments, says the neighbors mock him, and he uses laughter as a defense mechanism.

"They kept staring at me. He kept eye-balling me … and mocking me," Schiavelli said.

That's when Rockville Center police showed up to issue the 42-year-old two tickets, including one for "disturbing the peace the night before."

Now Schiavelli's attorney says he's fighting to keep his client out of jail.

"The day my client gets convicted for laughing, I'll quit practicing law, and I've been practicing for 20 years," Andrew Campanelli told ABC News. "The ordinance and prosecution are simply absurd."

Campanelli says the ordinance grants police the right to ticket anyone who's acting "in such a manner as to annoy, disturb, interfere with, obstruct or be offensive to others."

Each summons carries a $250 fine, and Schiavelli could face 15 days in jail.

In Tuesday's court hearing, Judge William Croutier said he "was not so inclined" to dismiss the charges, The Associated Press reported.

"Over the next two weeks, I'll be filling a motion to dismiss. I'm not going to allow him to plead guilty for laughing," Campanelli said. "We'll pursue federal court if needed."

View Comments (5780)

Recommended for You

  • Escaped Prisoners: How David Sweat and Richard Matt Survived 3 Weeks on the Run

    During escaped prisoners Richard Matt and David Sweat's three weeks on the run in upstate New York, Matt spent some time in a previously unknown camper in Franklin County, an official confirmed. Jon Chodat, who lives just down the road, told ABC News the camper that sheltered Matt, 48, from the…

    Good Morning America
  • Whitey Bulger Writes Contrite Letter to Teens, Says His Life Was 'Spent Foolishly'

    Mollykate Rodenbush, Brittany Tainsh and Michaela Arguin, now rising seniors at Apponequet Regional High School in Lakeville, Massachusetts, selected Bulger as the topic of their website for the National History Day competition earlier this year. A few teachers recommended they look at a local…

    Good Morning America
  • Father Describes How He and His Family Escaped a Plane Crashing Into Their Home

    A father's quick thinking helped save his wife and two children when a plane hit their Massachusetts home.Aaron Rice and his family survived the Sunday evening crash that killed all three on board when it hit the Rice family's home in Plainville, near the Rhode Island border."My wife and my boys…

    Good Morning America
  • Michael Douglas Loves Wife Catherine Zeta-Jones 'More Than Ever'

    Michael Douglas says he and wife Catherine Zeta-Jones are doing better than ever following their public separation in 2013. The 70-year-old "Ant-Man" star opened up in a new interview about his relationship with his wife, their two children and his life after cancer. "It feels like a rebirth…

    Good Morning America
  • How Police Caught Escaped Prisoners Richard Matt and David Sweat

    A three-week manhunt for two escaped prisoners, called a "nightmare" by New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, came to a violent end this past weekend when one inmate was shot and killed Friday and another was shot and apprehended Sunday. Officials announced they had reason to believe Sweat and Matt, who…

    Good Morning America
  • Royal Flush Is the Water Slide of Your Dreams and Nightmares

    The Royal Flush may have just won summer.Since a video of the new attraction was posted to YouTube earlier this month by ROUND III Media, it's been viewed more than 11 million times. Scroll down to see the video.Now, to be fair, the video does open with bikini-clad girls inexplicably carrying a…

    Good Morning America
  • 'The Bachelorette' Kaitlyn Bristowe Admits It's 'Tough' Dating Multiple Men

    As the star of "The Bachelorette," Kaitlyn Bristowe was romantically involved with several men. Juggling those relationships wasn't always easy, especially when some of the men, namely Shawn B., expressed that they were having a hard time dealing with feelings of jealousy.

    Good Morning America
  • Adorable Kid Helps Dad Pop the Question

    This cutie pie managed to help his dad pop the question without ever saying a word during a family photo shoot. Adam Blum decided to take advantage of the opportunity of the pre-planned shoot to pop the question to the 13-month-old boy's mom and his fiance, Hannah Roach, of Cape Girardeau,…

    Good Morning America
  • Walmart Apologizes for Making ISIS Cake for Man Denied Confederate Flag Design

    Chuck Netzhammer said he ordered the image of the Confederate flag on a cake with the words, "Heritage Not Hate," on Thursday at a Walmart in Slidell, Louisiana. A spokesman for Walmart told ABC News, "An associate in a local store did not know what the design meant and made a mistake. "That's an…

    Good Morning America
  • 'Duck Dynasty' Star John Luke Robertson Marries Mary Kate McEacharn

    "Duck Dynasty" star John Luke Robertson married Mary Kate McEacharn on Saturday on the family farm in West Monroe, Louisiana, his rep confirmed to ABC News. "It was one of the best days of my life! It was everything I hoped it would be and more," McEacharn told US Weekly about tying the knot. …

    Good Morning America
  • How Aaron Rodgers Helped Olivia Munn Prepare for 'X-Men'

    As Olivia Munn prepares for her big role in "X-Men: Apocalypse," she's getting some help -- kind of -- from her boyfriend Aaron Rodgers.Munn posted a video showing off her sword skills for her role as Betsy Braddock, aka Psylocke, and there's a familiar face, goofing off in the background."Learned…

    Good Morning America
  • Prison Escapees Richard Matt and David Sweat Were Headed to Mexico, Gov. Cuomo Says

    Prison escapees Richard Matt and David Sweat had originally planned to flee to Mexico before the two split up last week, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo said in a radio interview today. Investigators have already started getting important information from captured inmate Sweat, who is now undergoing…

    Good Morning America
  • Leap Second: Why Tuesday Will Be 1 Second Longer and Could Screw Up Your Computer

    A leap second will be added to the clock on the last day of June, creating the potential to wreak havoc on computer systems not equipped to handle the change. The International Earth Rotation and Reference Systems (IERS) said the extra second will be added to account for a discrepancy between…

    Good Morning America
  • Kendall Jenner Breaks Sister Kim Kardashian's Instagram Record

    Sorry, Kim Kardashian, but you no longer have the most-liked post on Instagram. That distinction now belongs to your younger sister, Kendall Jenner. Jenner, 19, set the record with a picture she posted over a month ago that now has 2.6 million likes.

    Good Morning America
  • Paul Rudd Reflects on 'Clueless' 20 Years Later

    It's been 20 years since Paul Rudd stole everyone's heart as Cher's love interest in "Clueless" and the A-lister recently took some time to reflect on the cult classic. "Who didn’t have a crush on Paul Rudd in Clueless?" the actor's "Ant-Man" co-star Evangeline Lilly said during a presser over the…

    Good Morning America
  • Waitress Tipped $1,000 by Her 'Guardian Angel' in Florida

    Kari Vanardoy was tipped $1,000 on a $29 bill at WingHouse in Largo on Wednesday, according to WingHouse general manager David Eschenfelder. Vanardoy – who works two jobs and has been at WingHouse for five years -- lives in a studio apartment and will now be able to move into a larger apartment…

    Good Morning America
  • Mystery Object Lights Up the Sky Over Parts of Georgia

    NASA has five meteor cameras in the southeast part of the U.S. that picked up video of the object that was moving at approximately 14,500 mph at 1:30 a.m. ET. William Cooke, lead for NASA Meteroid Environment Office, told ABC News today that “14,500 miles per hour is pretty fast, but it’s too slow…

    Good Morning America