Does the iPhone 5S Fingerprint Sensor Make it More Secure?

Good Morning America
Does the iPhone 5S Fingerprint Sensor Make it More Secure?
.

View photo

Does the iPhone 5S Fingerprint Sensor Make it More Secure? (ABC News)

After about a month of speculation, Phil Schiller, Apple's VP of marketing, announced Tuesday that the iPhone 5S would come equipped with a fingerprint sensor. Officially called Touch ID, the sensor and its software will let users access their iPhone and iTunes account via thumbprint. But will Touch ID actually make iPhones more secure?

"So much of our personal lives are on these devices. ... We have to protect them," said Schiller. The fingerprint sensor was a security measure that Apple installed, possibly in reaction to the fact that over half of iPhone users don't use a passcode. "Some people find [passcodes] too cumbersome," Schiller added.

Fingerprint readers themselves aren't a new invention, but they never quite made it into the mainstream. Anil Jain, a University Distinguished Professor of Computer Science at Michigan State University, said several other companies have tried to take advantage of the fingerprint as an unlocking device. "There have been laptops, USB sticks, car doors, hotel locks, and even Disney World tickets that have used fingerprints," he told ABC News. "But nothing's really taken off."

Perhaps one of the reasons why fingerprint scanners haven't found their footing in the marketplace is because they can be finicky. "You can't place your finger in any direction and then expect the fingerprint matching algorithm to accept it," said Jain. The state of your finger also matters, he added, noting that a dry finger may scan differently than a wet one or a lotioned one.

A fingerprint reader that doesn't work reliably can add to a user's frustration. It could be just as off-putting as mistyping a password. We didn't find that sort of fustration in our short time testing out the iPhone 5S' sensor. After registering a print it logged us in almost instantly and when another tried to unlock it with their thumb an error message read "try again."

But other security experts worry that a misread fingerprint might be the least of theworries, especially in regards to a device as ubiquitous as an iPhone.

"One security measure does not mean that the device is secure or that the applications on the device are secure," said Scott Matsumoto, principal consultant for the software security firm Cigital. "There's no one thing you can do that says, '*POOF*, you're secure!' Security is built up from a lot of small things."

Apple keeps its record of the fingerprint confined to the iPhone and not on an external server. However, Matsumoto said that users should be careful because the iPhone is both storing and validating a user's fingerprint in the same place. "The way that it's stored is very insecure," he said. "How do you change a fingerprint if it gets compromised? It's the last thing that I want to happen."

Ann Cavoukian, the Privacy Commissioner of Ontario, Canada, said that an Apple password breach might not be quite so catastrophic, provided that the company takes the right steps. "If Apple were to use biometric encryption, they would not be using the fingerprint itself as the password," she said, "Instead, they would store something meaningless as the password with the fingerprint as the key."

Cavoukian has had success in using biometric encryption in Ontario, particularly with video cameras armed with facial recognition that target gambling addicts and prevent them from trying to sneak into government-sponsored casinos. "I approved of this because the cameras used biometric encryption," she said. "Only the biometric record is retained on file, not the actual face."

If someone broke into an iPhone and stole the device's record of the fingerprint, it wouldn't affect the security of products and services outside of the iPhone. "They wouldn't get the actual fingerprint or ID, just some gibberish," said Cavoukian. Overall, she approves of the sensor. "I think it's a good idea, but the devil's in the details."

View Comments (30)

Recommended for You

  • 8-Year-Old Writes Hilarious Guide to Third Grade

    One 8-year-old has penned a hilarious, and brutally honest, how-to-guide for surviving third grade. Christopher Bannon, of Staten Island, New York, wrote the guide, simply titled “How to Survive 3rd Grade," for a school assignment, according to his mom, Melissa Barvels. Christopher and his…

    Good Morning America16 mins ago
  • Hillary Clinton Pans Donald Trump’s 1st Debate Performance: 'He Made It Very Clear That He Didn't Prepare'

    Hillary Clinton came out swinging against Donald Trump today after the first presidential debate of the general-election season, criticizing his post-performance gripes, questioning his wealth and suggesting a "strong probability" the GOP nominee has not paid federal income taxes in years. “He…

    Good Morning America17 mins ago
  • Ryan Lochte Protesters Are Charged

    The Los Angeles City Attorney's Office filed criminal complaints on Monday against Sam Sotoodeh and Barzeen Soroudi, who rushed the stage of the ABC show earlier this month to protest Lochte's casting. During the season premiere of "Dancing With the Stars," Sotoodeh and Soroudi interrupted the…

    Good Morning America22 mins ago
  • This Mom Threw Out Her Kids' Toys and Got Her Life Back

    Allie Casazza was drowning. In toys.“I had this huge room in my house, dedicated to toys,” she told ABC News. “Bins overflowing with stuff. A $150 light-up unicorn no one played with. The playroom was the bane of my existence.”She describes a scene familiar to many moms. “I’d send the kids into the…

    Good Morning America22 mins ago
  • Trump on Former Miss Universe Machado: 'She Gained a Massive Amount of Weight'

    Donald Trump pushed back against criticism he received from Hillary Clinton during last night's debate regarding his treatment of former Miss Universe Alicia Machado, saying "she gained a massive amount of weight, and it was a real problem."Trump made his remarks on "Fox and Friends" this morning…

    Good Morning America10 mins ago
  • Elderly Couple Reunited After Forced to Live in Separate Nursing Homes for Months

    The reunion, which was filled with "tears of joy," came after Wolfram Gottschalk, 83, and Anita Gottschalk, 81, were photographed crying in late August during a visitation a few months after they were first separated, according to their granddaughter, Ashley Bartyik. "This is the saddest photo I…

    Good Morning America
  • Princess Kate Dazzles in Red on Royal Tour of Canada

    Kate, 34, wore a bright red dress by British designer Preen to the diplomatic reception. Kate’s $1,300 red dress was the most formal outfit to date on the eight-day royal tour of Canada she is undertaking along with Prince William and their two children, Prince George and Princess Charlotte. Kate…

    Good Morning America
  • Why One Blogger Mom Says Parents Should Become More 'Average'

    One mom is advocating for a laid back approach to parenting, calling out “free-range” and “helicopter” parents and suggesting that moms and dads drop the labels and embrace being average.Blogger Ilana Wiles stopped by "Good Morning America" today to discuss her new book, "The Mommy Shorts Guide to…

    Good Morning America
  • Adele Honored for '25' Diamond Status

    If you needed further proof that Adele’s "25" continues to be a monster hit, here it is: the album has been certified 10-times platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America. That officially makes "25" a diamond-certified record.The singer was presented with a plaque celebrating the…

    Good Morning America
  • Tom Hanks Crashes Newlyweds' Photo Shoot in Central Park

    Tom Hanks made one couple's wedding day especially memorable after he crashed their photo shoot in Central Park this weekend.The bride and groom, named Elizabeth and Ryan, were accompanied by New York City-based photographer Meg Miller when Hanks approached them in the park and posed for…

    Good Morning America
  • Denzel Washington, Viola Davis Erupt in New 'Fences' Trailer

    A new teaser trailer for "Fences" was just released and it's beyond gripping and emotional. The acclaimed duo are back as Troy and Rose, a couple struggling with life and race relations in the 1950s. Washington and Davis go toe-to-toe in the clip, which shows Troy upset that his life hasn't…

    Good Morning America
  • Firefighter Killed, Multiple Injured After Explosion at Bronx Home With Possible Drug Lab, FDNY Says

    A firefighter was killed and multiple people were injured in an explosion and fire at a house in New York City today that contained evidence of a possible drug lab inside, according to the New York City Fire Department. FDNY Battalion Chief Michael Fahey and other local fire department members…

    Good Morning America
  • Donald Trump and the Perils of Little Preparation

    Members of his campaign team were trying to lower debate expectations of Trump, leaking to reporters that he was shunning policy briefings and not standing at faux lecterns for 90 minutes at a time in preparation. During the 90-minute debate, Trump never mentioned the 2012 attacks in Benghazi,…

    Good Morning America
  • Rescued Boater Expected in Boston Today as Mother Still Missing

    A rescued boater who spent eight days adrift at sea after his boat sank is expected to arrive in Boston today to be reunited with friends and family, even as his mother remained missing. Nathan Carman, 22, and his 54-year-old mother Linda Carman were reported missing on Sept. 18 after departing…

    Good Morning America
  • Donald Trump and Surrogates Heap Blame on Debate Moderator Lester Holt's Line of Questioning

    Donald Trump and his team are slamming presidential debate moderator Lester Holt for not asking Hillary Clinton questions Monday night about her email controversy and potential conflicts of interest with the Clinton Foundation, among other things. “He didn't ask her about the emails at all,” Trump…

    Good Morning America
  • Mystery Over Missing Mom Continues as Rescued Boater Arrives in Boston

    A boater who was recently rescued after spending eight days at sea in a life raft has finally arrived back on land in Boston, where he is expected to be reunited with family and friends and interviewed by the Coast Guard. Nathan Carman, 22, was dropped off in Boston's harbor this morning by a…

    Good Morning America
  • Stars React to the 1st Presidential Debate

    Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump faced off in the first presidential debate Monday night at Hofstra University on Long Island, New York.And immediately after the contentious back and forth between the Republican and Democratic nominees, stars took to Twitter and other forms of social media to voice…

    Good Morning America