Mo. College Sues Broke Couple Over $5M Pledge

Good Morning America
Mo. College Sues Broke Couple Over $5M Pledge

View photo

Mo. College Sues Broke Couple Over $5M Pledge (ABC News)

An Orange County, Calif., couple is fighting to appeal a lawsuit filed by the Kansas City Art Institute seeking $4 million they pledged to donate before the collapse of their business.

"They were so rude and obnoxious, it doesn't seem right to me," said Kristina Dodge, 51.

Dodge and her husband Lawrence Dodge, 73, of Dana Point, Calif., the founder of bank and insurance firm American Sterling Corp., had agreed to donate the money to the private art college before the financial collapse took away their businesses and left them unable to afford a lawyer to fight the case, they say.

The Dodges' donation was to support the Kansas City Art Institute's new $7 million 34,000-square-foot building, a total pledge of $5 million to be distributed from 2005 until 2013. The Dodges fulfilled the pledge for the first three years, giving $1 million.

But the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. seized the bank and sold its assets in April 2009. The California Insurance Commissioner later said the bank was "undercapitalized and has almost no liquid assets," the Kansas City Star reported.

Anne Canfield, Kansas City Art Institute's vice president for communications, told ABC News the college's board of trustees authorized the lawsuit by unanimous vote last year, "after nearly four years of discussion with the Dodges."

The college says the Dodges were informed of this action in a letter dated Aug. 11, 2011, "giving them every opportunity to respond."

Kristina Dodge told ABC News the school cut off communication "in a nasty manner."

"In fact, I would like to get my million dollars back from them," she said.

After the bank was seized, Dodge was banned from banking, for breaching his fiduciary duty by signing off on "false" reports describing the bank's risk, said the Treasury Department's Office of Thrift Supervision, later replaced by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. The office levied a $2.5 million civil penalty, which he later appealed and was reduced to $1 million. Dodge is also appealing that.

During the Dodges' professional struggles, the Kansas City Art Institute came knocking for the remaining $4 million. The college filed a lawsuit on July 28, 2011 to get the remainder of the money, alleging among other things breach of written contract and unjust enrichment from favorable publicity and having a building named after them.

The couple counters that they never asked for the building, the Lawrence and Kristina Dodge Painting Building, to be named after them.

Dodge says his only source of income now is from Social Security benefits. His wife, Kristina, 51, provides care for their children. The couple has a 13-year old daughter and triplets, who are two years old.

They say their lifestyle has "completely changed" since the company shut down. They borrowed money from friends and family and are selling belongings on eBay. They don't own any cars though they do still have real estate assets, which can't immediately provide them with cash.

They said they can't afford childcare, or a lawyer.

Though they say they did their best in filing a response to the lawsuit, paying filing fees and showing up for depositions, they still missed a court filing deadline to respond to the college's amended complaint. Missing that deadline led to a default $3.3 million judgment against them in May by the California Superior Court of Orange County, which the Dodges are now appealing.

The Dodges have been subpoenaed to appear for a debtors' exam on Dec. 13 during which they will be asked about their finances.

The Dodges say the nonprofit would not return their calls about trying to work out an agreement before the lawsuit. Meanwhile, they said a few other nonprofits to whom they had pledged money sympathized with their financial plight.

"The others have been absolutely amazing. Their care and concern has been the complete opposite of the Kansas City Art Institute," Dodge said. "It really restores our faith in humanity. Rather than having the vultures circle, they have asked what they can do to help."

Dodge said he wants to avoid bankruptcy though it is a possibility if his appeal is unsuccessful.

"We're still in our home," Kristina Dodge said. "Knock on wood."

Initially, she said she might have been willing to sell the home to help pay the obligation to the art institute. But she said the art institute's actions have made her less willing.

"So I decided I'm not giving up my home anymore," she said.

The Kansas City Art Institute maintains that they had a financial responsibility to recoup the $5 million, which was committed to cover the majority of the building's cost.

"The decision to proceed with a court action was not undertaken lightly, but our board concluded that it was necessary for KCAI to uphold its fiduciary responsibilities as a college and as a nonprofit organization," Canfield said in a statement.

She points out that nonprofit organizations are required by the Financial Accounting and Standards Board to report pledges on their accounting statements as a way to show all assets and resources, and failing to act to collect on could show a deficit in accounting and affect future pledges.

"Fiscal accountability is of utmost importance to KCAI," she said. "In this particular case, seeking to enforce this pledge is necessary in order for us to be accountable to all our donors who so generously support us, as well as to the students we serve in fulfilling our educational mission."

Holly Hall, features editor at the Chronicle of Philanthropy, said other nonprofits have gotten into legal tangles with donors over pledged money, but it is rare.

In January, a jury ordered a nonprofit hospital to return a $500,000 gift to the country music singer, Garth Brooks. The singer had sued Integris Canadian Valley Regional Hospital in Yukon, Okla., his hometown, over a disagreement over what to do with his $500,000 gift.

The donation was initially anonymous in 2005, but Brooks later requested that the hospital name a women's center after his mother, who died of cancer in 1999.

The hospital had to give back the $500,000 but also pay another $500,000 in damages, creating unwanted publicity and the need for clearer agreements between donors and charities, Hall said.

Most disputes over pledged money take place after donors have died and charities fear the heirs will fight over an estate. Either way, Hall says legal tangles with donors are risky endeavors on the part of the charities.

"The issue is they would be perceived as someone going after them when, through little or no fault of their own, they fell on hard times," Hall said. "That could make other donors hesitant to get into large gift agreements."

Kenneth Fitzgerald, a pro-bono attorney for the Dodges, said pursuing a default judgment on a couple who say they cannot afford an attorney is "mean-spirited and short sighted."

"I don't think they have a fiduciary duty to put one of their most generous donors into bankruptcy and unleash their lawyers and terrorize these people when they are destitute," Fitzgerald said. "It makes sense that they would want to collect a pledge if it's collectible. In this case, they know it's not."

View Comments (1)

Recommended for You

  • Ariana Grande, Bob Dylan, Eric Clapton, Mudcrutch and More Music Reviews

    This week Ariana Grande returns with a more mature image, Bob Dylan drops another collection of standards, Eric Clapton hints at a goodbye, Tom Petty reforms his pre-Heartbreakers band Mudcrutch for their second outing, Blake Shelton sings about falling-apart relationships and blossoming new ones,…

    Good Morning America47 mins ago
  • Chaotic Scene Erupts Outside Trump Rally in New Mexico

    Throngs of protesters gathered outside the rally in Albuquerque and several protesters were escorted out of the rally earlier. At one point, protesters broke through a barricade erected by police, rushing the convention center where Trump was speaking. While Albuquerque police prevented them from…

    Good Morning America
  • ‘Dancing With the Stars’ Finale 2016: Nyle DiMarco Wins Mirror Ball Trophy in Season 22

    Model/actor Nyle DiMarco won season 22 of “Dancing With the Stars” tonight, beating out UFC fighter Paige VanZant and “GMA” meteorologist Ginger Zee to take the coveted mirror ball trophy. DiMarco jumped when the results were revealed before being quickly engulfed in hugs from supporters and his…

    Good Morning America
  • Craig Sager to Receive Jimmy V Perseverance Award at ESPYS

    It wouldn't be the ESPYS without the Jimmy V Perseverance Award, and this year's recipient couldn't be more deserving. Craig Sager, 64, was diagnosed with leukemia just two years ago and has shared his battle with the sports world while still working on the sidelines at TNT. Sager -- who has…

    Good Morning America
  • CDC Official Says Thousands May Have Arrived in US With Zika

    Federal health officials today said they believe thousands of people may have contracted the Zika virus before returning to the U.S. and they remain concerned that the virus might commence ongoing transmission in the U.S. Speaking at a panel at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars,…

    Good Morning America
  • Cosby Ordered to Stand Trial in Sex Assault Case

    Comedian Bill Cosby has been ordered to stand trial in the 2004 indecent assault case brought against him last December. The 78-year-old comedian appeared today in a Pennsylvania courtroom, where District Judge Elizabeth McHugh heard portions of accuser Andrea Constand’s statements to police. …

    Good Morning America
  • Brad Pitt Helps Save Young Fan From Being Crushed in Crowd

    While shooting his upcoming World War II film, "Allied," in Spain's Canary Islands, the actor took a break to greet fans. In a video of the incident, Pitt can be seen pointing to the girl before rushing over to help her.

    Good Morning America
  • Lawmakers Occupy Hot Car in Push to Allow Pet-Saving Bystanders to Smash Windows

    The proposed bill would allow passersby to smash car windows to rescue pets trapped in hot cars. To drive home the point, Assemblymembers Ling Ling Chang, Kristin Olsen and Marc Steinorth, who drafted the bill, filmed themselves locked inside a car for 21 minutes while the temperature outside was…

    Good Morning America
  • American ISIS Wannabe Nabbed in Elaborate Sting, FBI Says

    Federal officials arrested a young New York City man today for allegedly supporting ISIS — the culmination of an elaborate FBI and NYPD sting operation in which the 22-year-old was duped by at least four undercover law enforcement agents, according to court documents. Bronx resident Sajmir…

    Good Morning America
  • Feds Seeking Death Penalty Against Alleged Charleston Church Shooter Dylann Roof

    The Justice Department is seeking the death penalty against Dylann Roof, who allegedly opened fire inside a Charleston, South Carolina, church last year, killing nine people. "Following the department’s rigorous review process to thoroughly consider all relevant factual and legal issues, I have…

    Good Morning America
  • Chelsea Handler Doesn’t Care What People Think of Her New Show

    Chelsea Handler has made a career out of being unapologetic, unafraid and sometimes half-naked. On "Chelsea," Handler has done everything from having dinner parties with movie stars to trips to Japan so she can learn how to become a geisha and a Harajuku girl. And while it's a late-night talk…

    Good Morning America
  • Paul McCartney Reveals What Really Split Up the Beatles

    Paul McCartney is now opening up about the tough times after the Beatles split in 1970. After the breakup, McCartney added, he wasn't sure "whether I was still going to continue in music." Fortunately for the music world, he ended up recording upward of 25 studio albums post-Beatles. He dropped…

    Good Morning America
  • Sophisticated Burglary of NYC Bank Through Roof Is the Latest in Series of Heists by 'Pros,' Police Say

    Thieves robbed a New York City bank over the weekend, apparently by cutting a wide hole in the roof, police said, noting that the sophisticated heist at the Maspeth Federal Savings branch in Rego Park, Queens, is the tenth of its kind across New York City. A bank employee first saw the gaping hole…

    Good Morning America
  • Stray Feline Believed to Be a Rare ‘Werewolf’ Kitten Found in South Africa

    Skeptical of Eyona's identity, Mandy Store, the feline expert at TEARS, contacted Dr. Johnny Gobble, a veterinarian from Sweetwater, Tennessee, whose wife, Brittney, established the Lykoi as a breed. Gobble confirmed to the rescue group that Eyona was a rare Lykoi -- a natural mutation of the…

    Good Morning America
  • Bernie Sanders Blasts Hillary Clinton's Refusal to Debate as 'Insulting' to Voters

    Bernie Sanders blasted Hillary Clinton for her refusal to debate him two weeks before the California Democratic primary. "Our campaign and her campaign had reached an agreement on a number of debates including one here in California in May," Sanders said during a rally in Santa Monica, California,…

    Good Morning America
  • Kim Kardashian and Kanye West Celebrate Their Second Wedding Anniversary

    Yes, it has been two years since Kim Kardashian and Kanye West tied the knot. Kardashian, 35, also posted other pics, including one of her huge engagement ring. West, 38, and Kardashian were married two years ago in Florence.

    Good Morning America
  • Tye Sheridan Talks Challenges of Playing Cyclops in 'X-Men: Apocalypse'

    The film finds the mutant superheros battling the world's first mutant, Apocalypse, (Oscar Isaac), who recruits his Four Horsemen - Magneto (Michael Fassbender), Psylocke (Olivia Munn), Storm (Alexandra Shipp) and Angel (Ben Hardy) to carry out his nefarious plans. "It's me and Brian Smrz, our…

    Good Morning America
  • Ferocious Solar Storms May Have Helped Life Take Root on Earth, NASA Says

    Ferocious solar storms 4 billion years ago may have been key to warming the Earth and creating the right conditions for life to form on the planet, according to a new study by a team of NASA scientists. NASA's Kepler mission discovered young sun-like stars and found they released "superflares,"…

    Good Morning America
  • Police Officers Join Kids for Soccer Game After Complaint Calls

    A group of police officers who responded to complaint calls about kids playing in a parking lot started a pick-up game of soccer with the kids instead of kicking them off the lot. Birmingham, Alabama, police officer Jordan Burke told ABC News his department had received several complaints over a…

    Good Morning America
  • Middle School Band Brings End-of-Year Concert to Bandmate's Front Yard

    A middle school band brought its end-of-year concert to the home of its missing flutist, who was home recovering from a kidney transplant. Emily underwent a kidney transplant earlier this year and an extended hospital stay forced her to miss her band’s final concert of the year on May 12. “She…

    Good Morning America