Newly Legal: Buying Stock in Start-Ups Via Crowdsourcing

ABC News
Newly Legal: Buying Stock in Start-Ups Via Crowdsourcing

View photo

Newly Legal: Buying Stock in Start-Ups Via Crowdsourcing (ABC News)

Amateur investors may soon be able to use crowdsourcing to buy equity in start-ups. But should they? At least one expert--the author of a report on Kickstarter--recommends caution.

Under a newly implemented provision of 2012's "Jumpstart Our Business Start-ups Act" (JOBS Act), it became legal this week for small start-ups to solicit investments publicly, via the Internet. They can sell shares without first having to register them with the Securities and Exchange Commission.

An entrepreneur in need of cash can raise up to $1 million a year, provided he or she sells shares only to "accredited" investors—meaning ones who can show they have a net worth of more than $1 million or income of over $200,000 a year.

Such sites as RockThePost already sell equity to accredited investors, who lawmakers and regulators regard as being more sophisticated than less-affluent ones (and thus better able to assess the risks inherent in new means of funding).

Ethan Mollick, a professor of management at the Wharton School of Business, has studied social media funding platforms extensively. His paper, "The Dynamics of Crowdfunding: An Exploratory Study," looks at the outcomes of some 48,500 Kickstarter projects, which collectively raised $237 million donated dollars.


He tells ABC News, "It's an interesting world right now. As of this week, a new opportunity has opened up for qualified investors."

At least 1,000 companies, he says, are lined up to get in on this business.

The reason they're lined up, Mollick says, is that they expect that the SEC will eventually decide to remove or to vitiate the "accredited" requirement, thus making it possible for grandma to invest her money in companies pursuing perpetual motion.

While selling equity to un-accredited investors on the Internet would be new, raising money—through sites like Kickstarter and Indiegogo—definitely is not. Mollick became curious to see how Kickstarter's projects had performed: How many reached their funding targets? Of those, how many delivered on time whatever it was they had promised to give donors? How many failed to deliver at all?

His findings, to the extent they bear on the Internet sale of equities, offer cause for both hope and fear.

Kickstarter doesn't sell equities—or at least it hasn't yet. What Kickstarter offers, explains company spokesperson Justin Kazmark, "is not an investment. It's not a donation. It's not a purchase." The thing being offered, though, shares the attributes of all those three, he says, while being something new and different: "You are pledging money to help bring an idea to life. You're getting updates [from the creative team trying to bring the project to fruition], you're getting vicarious participation in the process, you're getting bragging rights and the satisfaction of knowing that you helped."

Participants might be offered first crack at buying the product, once it's been produced. They might be offered and "gift" T-shirt or other expression of thanks. But they don't own a slice of the undertaking, nor are they making a purpose, according to Kickstarter.

So, what happens if you pledge $150 to help fund somebody's movie, and the maker fails to reach his funding goal? Do you get your money back? You never parted with your money in the first place, because Kickstarter does not debit your credit card unless and until the funding goal is met. If the goal isn't met by the project's deadline, Kickstarter pulls the plug. The person seeking funding, no matter how close to meeting his goal he may have been, gets nothing. So there's nothing to refund.

What happens if the creator fails to deliver on-time whatever was promised—the T-shirt, say? You wait and grumble. Aggravations such as this, says Kazmark, are between the funders and the creators. Kickstarter chooses not to get involved. "Delays happen a fair amount," he says. "But it's uncommon for a project just to disappear or fall off the face of the earth."

It does, though, happen.

Kickstarter does not provide detailed statistics on the outcome of its funding campaigns. Nor does it track how or on what the money got spent. Mollick, though, has done his own analysis, in which Kickstarter did not participate. To make his findings, he and two graduate assistants combed the Internet for every Kickstarter campaign about which they could find information. "We assessed whether what was promised was delivered or not, whether it was late. We looked on Facebook for complaints by contributors."

Asked to give examples of Kickstarter campaigns gone wrong, he says the most famous to date was one to develop eyeglasses capable of capturing video. That project, he says, has now "gone silent," with the creators saying nothing about the disposition of the more than $300,000 raised. He says there also have been "many" campaigns in the $40,000 range that remain unaccounted for.


Kickstarter's website says that creators who have received funding have an obligation to return it to their donors, if they find they cannot complete their projects or deliver on their promises.

Mollick's research shows that the incidence of these negative outcomes is small. "Failure to deliver is under 4 percent of projects," he says, "and less than 1 percent of money raised."

The incidence of outright fraud, too, is low, he says, in part because the online dialog between donors and creators is public and completely open. "When something suspicious comes up, there are lots of eyeballs to see it," Mollick says.

He gives the example of an effort to raise money to produce a super-premium brand of Kobe beef jerky. The funding campaign sailed along happily until a would-be contributor who knew something about jerky asked why Kobe would be the right beef to use: wasn't it too fatty? Wasn't the best jerky lean? Somebody else asked what the tag numbers were for the beef (portions of Kobe beef are identified by serial number, Mollick says).

When plausible answers to these questions were not forthcoming, donors blew the whistle, and Kickstarter took down the page. No money ever changed hands.

Regarding the sale of equities, Mollick says he sees the greatest potential for fraud in situations where the crowdsourcing site does not permit open, public communication between investors or between investors and the entrepreneurs. Questionable, too, would be sites that make no claim to have exercised sufficient diligence to confirm that their cash-soliciting ventures are legit.

What signs should inspire confidence? "If the principals behind the start-up have prior experience in their industry, that's good. If they've got a working prototype of what it is they want to make, that's good, too. If those are lacking, your alarm bell ought to go off."

Mollick says that for the present the SEC has adopted an attitude of "wait and see." On the one hand, he says, the intent of the JOBS Act is to make it easier for legitimate start-ups to raise money. On the other, the SEC has a responsibility to protect investors from fraud. "There's some danger of fraud in this kind of funding. That's the reason for the qualified-investor rule."

Asked the best word to describe regulators' attitude right now, he opts for two: "Worried, nervous."

View Comments (4)

Recommended for You

  • Friend of Man Boating With Marlins Pitcher Jose Fernandez Texted Stay 'Close to Shore'

    The friend of a man who died along with Miami Marlins star pitcher Jose Fernandez, sent a text message warning to "please be careful" and "keep him close to shore," according to a screen shot posted to social media. The texts, posted to Instagram by Will Bernal Sunday, offered some potential…

    Good Morning America26 mins ago
  • Quintuplet Siblings All Employed at Same McDonald's

    In a funny occurrence, one set of quintuplets are working for the same McDonald's restaurant together near their Michigan home. The now-18-year-old high school seniors are all part-time employees at the same McDonald's location in Potterville. "The first two came on a little over a year ago and…

    Good Morning America27 mins ago
  • SpaceX Unveils Plan for Manned Mars Mission

    According to a video posted on Twitter, the process will involve launching a reusable rocket booster to refuel a spaceship mid-orbit, followed by the deployment of the spaceship’s solar array as the ship begins its journey to the Red Planet. Today’s announcement comes less than a month after a…

    Good Morning America28 mins ago
  • Hillary Clinton Pans Donald Trump's 1st Debate Performance: 'He Made It Very Clear That He Didn't Prepare'

    Hillary Clinton came out swinging against Donald Trump today after the first presidential debate of the general-election season, criticizing his post-performance gripes, questioning his wealth and suggesting a "strong probability" the GOP nominee has not paid federal income taxes in years. "He…

    Good Morning America34 mins ago
  • Serena Williams 'Won't Be Silent' on Race-Related Police Incidents

    Serena Williams took to Facebook today, writing in a lengthy post that she won't be silent any longer when it comes to race relations and police-involved incidents in America. But Williams, 35, then wrote she remembered the case of Philando Castile, who was shot after he was pulled over in…

    Good Morning America46 mins ago
  • Denzel Washington, Viola Davis Erupt in New 'Fences' Trailer

    A new teaser trailer for "Fences" was just released and it's beyond gripping and emotional. The acclaimed duo are back as Troy and Rose, a couple struggling with life and race relations in the 1950s. Washington and Davis go toe-to-toe in the clip, which shows Troy upset that his life hasn't…

    Good Morning America56 mins ago
  • How Hillary Clinton Got Under Donald Trump's Skin During the Debate

    One of the big questions Monday night was how Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump would try to goad each other into losing their cool during their first face-off. Aaron Kall, the director of debate at the University of Michigan, said he thought Clinton’s attack on Trump's tax returns "was the most…

    Good Morning America
  • Man Arrested in Connection With Bronx Blast That Killed Firefighter, Injured More Than a Dozen Others

    Julio Salcedo, 32, was arrested this afternoon in Cliffside Park, New Jersey, the law enforcement source said. Fire officials and police originally responded to the single-family house in the Bronx this morning after receiving a report of a gas odor, Fire Commissioner Dan Nigro said at a news…

    Good Morning America
  • Jennifer Aniston's Husband Justin Theroux Sounds Off on Brad Pitt's Divorce

    After news broke last week that Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie were splitting, the Jennifer Aniston memes began. Fans took to social media to post jokes involving Pitt's first ex-wife. Aniston and Pitt were married from 2000 to 2005.

    Good Morning America
  • Men Charged After Protesting Ryan Lochte on 'Dancing With the Stars'

    The Los Angeles City Attorney's Office filed criminal complaints on Monday against Sam Sotoodeh and Barzeen Soroudi, who rushed the stage of the ABC show earlier this month to protest Lochte's casting. During the season premiere of "Dancing With the Stars," Sotoodeh and Soroudi interrupted the…

    Good Morning America
  • Donald Trump and the Perils of Little Preparation

    Members of his campaign team were trying to lower debate expectations of Trump, leaking to reporters that he was shunning policy briefings and not standing at faux lecterns for 90 minutes at a time in preparation. During the 90-minute debate, Trump never mentioned the 2012 attacks in Benghazi,…

    Good Morning America
  • Stars React to the 1st Presidential Debate

    Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump faced off in the first presidential debate Monday night at Hofstra University on Long Island, New York.And immediately after the contentious back and forth between the Republican and Democratic nominees, stars took to Twitter and other forms of social media to voice…

    Good Morning America
  • This Mom Threw Out Her Kids' Toys and Got Her Life Back

    Allie Casazza was drowning. In toys.“I had this huge room in my house, dedicated to toys,” she told ABC News. “Bins overflowing with stuff. A $150 light-up unicorn no one played with. The playroom was the bane of my existence.”She describes a scene familiar to many moms. “I’d send the kids into the…

    Good Morning America
  • Young Girl's Emotional Council Speech Laments 'Shame' of Fatal Charlotte Shooting

    Peaceful protesters crowded Charlotte's first city council meeting since the cop shooting of Keith Lamont Scott, with over 50 people speaking out against police violence. Zianna Oliphant, her hair done up in braids and tears streaking her face, brought into focus the stress police shootings place…

    Good Morning America
  • Trump on Former Miss Universe Machado: 'She Gained a Massive Amount of Weight'

    Trump made his remarks on "Fox and Friends" this morning in response to Clinton's pointing out that Trump called Machado "Miss Piggy" and blasting the Republican nominee's overall treatment of women. "She was the winner, and, you know, she gained a massive amount of weight, and it was a real…

    Good Morning America
  • 8-Year-Old Writes Hilarious Guide to Third Grade

    One 8-year-old has penned a hilarious, and brutally honest, how-to-guide for surviving third grade. Christopher Bannon, of Staten Island, New York, wrote the guide, simply titled “How to Survive 3rd Grade," for a school assignment, according to his mom, Melissa Barvels. Christopher and his…

    Good Morning America
  • Mike Pence Says Donald Trump 'Took Command of the Stage' in Debate

    Republican vice presidential candidate Mike Pence today praised Donald Trump's Monday night debate performance. Pence also said Trump was just making his positions clear when he reversed course on the birther issue. "Donald Trump has been focused on a stronger America at home and abroad," Pence…

    Good Morning America