A 'Picasso' That an Ohio Man Bought in a Thrift Store Sold for $7,000

Good Morning America

Zachary Bodish, 46, of Columbus, Ohio, bought what he thought was a poster reproduction advertising an exhibit of Pablo Picasso for $14.14 in a thrift store and sold it for $7,000 to a private buyer.

Bodish, 46, said he went to a Volunteers of America store in Clintonville, Ohio on March 1. He was looking for mid-century furniture housewards or "kitschy art" to re-sell. Bodish, who lost his job as a house manager at the Wexner Center for the Arts about two years ago, uses the hobby to supplement his income. He has a part-time job as he looks for more permanent work in the arts.

"I would have liked to have kept it but I'm somewhat underemployed at the moment," Bodish said. "I really needed the money. If it hadn't been worth very much, only $2,000, I probably would have kept it."

Bodish said a few buyers had made an offer and he had even met with a representative at Christie's auction house in New York City. That representative estimated verbally that Christie's could list the piece in its catalog for $2,500 to $3,000 and it could sell for $4,000, Bodish said.

No one he spoke to gave him an offer as high as the final bidder, who contacted Bodish through the phone book.

"This particular buyer. We just got along well," Bodish said.

Because the piece was never officially appraised on paper, the buyer took a leap of faith that it was authentic.

"He felt fairly confident," Bodish said of the buyer, who has given Bodish "visitation rights."

"I think all parties were pretty darn happy about it," Bodish said of the transaction.

The owner who donated the piece to the thrift store said a friend gave the print to him as a gift in the 1960s. Ed Zettler, a retired teacher from Columbus, acknowledges he gave up his rights to the print when he donated it.

"I'm glad that the guy that got it recognized something about it," Zettler told the Columbus Dispatch after the newspaper first reported about the thrifty discovery. "I am pleased for him."

Though Bodish never had the print appraised, Picasso experts said the work is most likely a linocut for which Picasso carved a design into linoleum that was then pressed onto paper with ink by a printer.

Todd Weyman, vice president of Swann Auction Galleries in New York City, had estimated that, if authentic, the print's fair market value at auction could be $4,000 to $6,000, based on sales of comparable works during the past 10 to 15 years.

On April 25, Swann Auction Galleries sold a Picasso linocut with three colors for $7,500 which was estimated to bring in about $10,000 to $15,000.

Weyman said an auction for a similar linocut through Christie's in London sold for $4,700 in March 2007. Another was sold in March 2006 through Sotheby's of London for $4,600.

Picasso created the "poster" from the thrift store for an annual pottery show for the city of Vallauris, France in 1958, according to Lisa Florman, an art professor at The Ohio State University. Picasso may have made prints for the annual exhibition every year from 1954 for several years.

In addition to the 100 numbered "original" linocuts, which were signed by the artist, it is possible some photolithographic reproductions were made, Florman said.

View photo

Possible signature of Pablo Picasso on back of print (Courtesy Zachary Bodish)

"These would have been what were plastered on walls throughout Vallauris and many neighboring towns in France," she said.

By that time, Picasso was one of the most famous artists in the world and a "real celebrity in France certainly," Florman said.

Bodish estimates that the printed area of the work measures 17 1/2 by 11 3/4 inches. Kobi Ledor who owns California-based Ledor Fine Art with his wife, Casey, who deal exclusively in works by Picasso, said the length and width should each be 1/4 inch longer to be an authentic piece.

"Though there is typically some variability in size," Ledor said, a 1/4-inch variance is at the "upper range of acceptability."

Ledor, who only viewed a digital photo of the print, said he has "doubts" about the authenticity of the signature, though the color may have been distorted photographically.

First, Ledor said that it was "odd" that the signature appears to have faded unevenly.

"They generally fade homogeneously, and I have seen no exceptions to that rule," he said.

Second, the color of the red pencil that Picasso typically used to sign his prints was "a red bordering on orange, which fades to orange, then yellow or pale yellowish/brown, then disappears."

"There are many authentic, original Picasso prints with forged signatures, so a forged signature on this find would not necessarily damn the artwork," he said. "A forger could have easily used the wrong type of pencil."

Last, Ledor said it is "unusual" that the "P" in Picasso's name dips below the underlining, "but there are a number of known exceptions to that."

Florman said in 1954, when he was 72, Picasso discovered the linocut technique and advertisements for the Vallauris ceramics exhibitions were among the very first sorts of linocuts he made.

"Most of his early ones used only a single color and were quite simple in design," she said. "In that sense, they are remarkably similar to his ceramic work, for which he also typically used only one or two colors at a time and kept things simple. The image on the 1958 Vallauris linocut is, I think, meant to depict a plate of the sort that Picasso often made -- the "pattern" being simply a human face."

View Comments (121)

Recommended for You

  • Ariel Winter Shares Sweet Pics From Prom

    Ariel Winter is growing up right before our eyes.The "Modern Family" star, 18, went to her senior prom over the weekend and shared snaps from the big night on social media.For her special event, Winter wore a strapless mermaid-style dress that hugged her curves. She complemented the black-and-white…

    Good Morning America
  • George Zimmerman Explains His Rationale for Auctioning Pistol That Killed Trayvon Martin

    Amid a storm of outrage and criticism, George Zimmerman on Monday explained publicly for the first time why he auctioned off the pistol he used to kill unarmed black teenager Trayvon Martin during an altercation in 2012. A Black Lives Matter community Facebook page has over 130,000 "likes" and…

    Good Morning America11 mins ago
  • Cosby Ordered to Stand Trial in Sex Assault Case

    A judge ruled today the indecent assault case against comedian Bill Cosby can go forward.Get real-time updates as this story unfolds.To start, just "star" this story in ABC News' phone app. Download ABC News for iPhone here or ABC News for Android here.

    Good Morning America12 mins ago
  • First Baby Girl Born in Florida Hospital Returns 29 Years Later to Give Birth

    History repeated itself at one Florida hospital when the first baby girl ever to be born there returned to have her own baby girl 29 years later.Tami Replogle was born on April 2, 1987, at Broward Health Coral Springs, just one month after the hospital opened its doors.At 6:31 a.m. on Monday, Tami…

    Good Morning America13 mins ago
  • Ferocious Solar Storms May Have Helped Life Take Root on Earth, NASA Says

    Ferocious solar storms 4 billion years ago may have been key to warming the Earth and creating the right conditions for life to form on the planet, according to a new study by a team of NASA scientists. NASA's Kepler mission discovered young sun-like stars and found they released "superflares,"…

    Good Morning America13 mins ago
  • Bernie Sanders Blasts Hillary Clinton's Refusal to Debate as 'Insulting' to Voters

    Bernie Sanders blasted Hillary Clinton for her refusal to debate him two weeks before the California Democratic primary. "Our campaign and her campaign had reached an agreement on a number of debates including one here in California in May," Sanders said during a rally in Santa Monica, California,…

    Good Morning America13 mins ago
  • HBO Comedian John Oliver in Online Tussle With Chechnya's Brutal Leader

    Comedian John Oliver has gotten into an unlikely long-distance spat with the feared president of Chechnya, Ramzan Kadyrov, on the improbable subject of the leader’s lost cat, a toyger. Appointed by Russian President Vladimir Putin in 2007, Kadyrov, 39, controls a private army of tens of thousands…

    Good Morning America15 mins ago
  • Vet Student Finds Tick on Sick Dog 1 Minute Before He Was Due to Be Euthanized

    About a week after 10-year-old Ollie returned home to Portland, Oregon, from an outdoor trip, his owner Al -- who asked that his last name not be used -- noticed the usually active dog seemed increasingly lethargic and weak. Ollie's regular veterinarian conducted tests, including blood work and…

    Good Morning America45 mins ago
  • Sophisticated Burglary of NYC Bank Through Roof Is the Latest in Series of Heists by 'Pros,' Police Say

    Thieves robbed a New York City bank over the weekend, apparently by cutting a wide hole in the roof, police said, noting that the sophisticated heist at the Maspeth Federal Savings branch in Rego Park, Queens, is the tenth of its kind across New York City. A bank employee first saw the gaping hole…

    Good Morning America57 mins ago
  • 3 Dead, 2 Still Missing Climbing Mount Everest

    Three climbers have died, and two others are still missing after attempting to climb Mount Everest, officials told ABC News this morning. All of them died of altitude sickness, according to Nepal tourism official Gyanendra Shrestha. ABC News previously reported that four climbers were killed, but…

    Good Morning America58 mins ago
  • Lawmakers Occupy Hot Car in Push to Allow Pet-Saving Bystanders to Smash Windows

    The proposed bill would allow passersby to smash car windows to rescue pets trapped in hot cars. To drive home the point, Assemblymembers Ling Ling Chang, Kristin Olsen and Marc Steinorth, who drafted the bill, filmed themselves locked inside a car for 21 minutes while the temperature outside was…

    Good Morning America
  • How Parents Can Help Kids Avoid Dangerous Online Interactions With Strangers

    Parents should beware that predators may be using online gaming to target their children. This woman, whom “Good Morning America” is referring to as Susan, says a stranger approached her son while he was playing “Clash of Clans” online with a group of friends. Her son, whom “Good Morning America”…

    Good Morning America
  • Kim Kardashian and Kanye West Celebrate Their Second Wedding Anniversary

    Yes, it has been two years since Kim Kardashian and Kanye West tied the knot. Kardashian, 35, also posted other pics, including one of her huge engagement ring. West, 38, and Kardashian were married two years ago in Florence.

    Good Morning America
  • Woman Who Was Arrested for Letting 11-Year-Old Son Drive Golf Cart Speaks Out

    A North Carolina mother of two who was charged with child abuse last year after letting her 11-year-old son drive a golf cart during a family vacation is now sharing her story publicly. Julie and Scott Mall were watching a sunset on exclusive Bald Head Island off the coast of North Carolina last…

    Good Morning America
  • 'Bachelorette' Recap: JoJo Meets Her Suitors and Gets Her First Kiss

    JoJo Fletcher’s first night as “The Bachelorette” on Monday night was filled with men, alcohol and a surprise visitor. On the season premiere of the hit ABC reality series, JoJo, the runner-up on Ben Higgins’ season of "The Bachelor" earlier this year, welcomed more than two dozen suitors to the…

    Good Morning America
  • The Jennifer Lopez Balancing Act: Her Secret to Success as Mom and Performer Revealed

    From actress to pop star to mother to fashion icon, Jennifer Lopez continues to impress by balancing her life like few celebrities can, and most recently tacking on a new Las Vegas show to her schedule. The musical powerhouse, 46, debuted her Las Vegas "All I have" residency in January to…

    Good Morning America
  • Paul McCartney Reveals What Really Split Up the Beatles

    Paul McCartney is now opening up about the tough times after the Beatles split in 1970. After the breakup, McCartney added, he wasn't sure "whether I was still going to continue in music." Fortunately for the music world, he ended up recording upward of 25 studio albums post-Beatles. He dropped…

    Good Morning America
  • Tye Sheridan Talks Challenges of Playing Cyclops in 'X-Men: Apocalypse'

    The film finds the mutant superheros battling the world's first mutant, Apocalypse, (Oscar Isaac), who recruits his Four Horsemen - Magneto (Michael Fassbender), Psylocke (Olivia Munn), Storm (Alexandra Shipp) and Angel (Ben Hardy) to carry out his nefarious plans. "It's me and Brian Smrz, our…

    Good Morning America
  • Facebook Trending Topics Will Undergo Changes Following Allegations of Political Bias

    Facebook is making several changes to its trending topics feature following an investigation stemming from anonymous allegations of political bias, the social network's general counsel announced in a newsroom post on Monday. Facebook launched an investigation earlier this month after tech website…

    Good Morning America
  • Twitter Makes It Easier to Squeeze in More Than 140 Characters

    Twitter's 140-character limit, which has long been the foundation of the site, is being relaxed in a move the social network hopes will make it easier for users to tweet more media-rich content without worrying about running out of characters. Twitter plans to "simplify" tweets by no longer…

    Good Morning America