Small Potatoes, Not: Suit Alleges OPEC-like Tuber Cartel

ABC News
Small Potatoes, Not: Suit Alleges OPEC-like Tuber Cartel
.

View photo

Small Potatoes, Not: Suit Alleges OPEC-like Tuber Cartel (ABC News)

You, maybe, think the idea of a "spud conspiracy" sounds silly. America's grocers most assuredly do not.

Associated Wholesale Grocers, which according to its website represents 1,900 retail stores, claims that America's potato producers have conspired to fix spud prices in the $25 billion a year industry. Their complaint, filed in Kansas' U.S. District Court, demands unspecified treble damages for what they claim are violations of the Sherman Act and the Kansas Restraint of Trade Act.

The grocers allege that potato growers in 12 states, controlling 80 percent of total U.S. potato acreage, have engaged in a conspiracy to fix prices--using OPEC as their model. That makes everyone's French fries, hash browns and mash more expensive, driving up the prices on many more potato-associated products.

Reads the complaint: "Defendants analogized their potato cartel to the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries ("OPEC")—the notorious petroleum supply-reduction and price-fixing cartel composed of various foreign nations."

A request by ABC News for comment from the grocers' attorneys got no response. United Potato Growers of America (UPGA) give this statement to ABC News: "United Potato Grower's goal has been to help growers provide quality potatoes at reasonable prices to American consumers. We have always acted openly and within the bounds of the law. We are confident in our legal position and look forward to a favorable outcome in court."

The grocers allege that growers and shippers used both pre-harvest and post-harvest methods to control and reduce the supply of taters, to raise and stabilize prices. Their methods included a deliberate reduction of potato acreage, destruction of potato inventory, and a limitation of the number of potatoes available for sale, the result being a "dramatic increase in the prices of potatoes."

The suit recounts what it describes as the formation and operation, starting in 2003, of the defendants' "potato cartel." First, it alleges, growers in Idaho formed a cooperative to fix prices; then, growers in other states did likewise in a coordinated campaign.

The cartel, says the compliant, convened a meeting in November 2004 where "several hundred" growers from California, Colorado, Oregon, Washington, Wisconsin and Idaho gave a "standing ovation" to their leader when he laid out his price-fixing plan.

The suit quotes a 2007 article in High Country News—"The Sultans of Spuds"—that describes a meeting of the group:

"These men are the leaders of a little-known international cartel, and at meetings such as these, they fine-tune an elaborate system of production targets and quota transfers to control the price of the commodity around which their world revolves. It is a serious business, backed up with reconnaissance from satellites orbiting high above the Earth, and the organization's strict code of conduct allows for the use of what its members artfully refer to as 'punitive measures' against anyone who violates the rules."

In a 2006 survey of growers by "Spudman" magazine, 85 percent said that since the formation of the UPGA they had seen an increase in profits.

U.S. law—the Capper-Volstead Act—permits agricultural cooperatives to engage in a variety of practices that otherwise would be considered anti-trust. It allows producers, collectively, to process, prepare, handle and market their products, for example. The University of Wisconsin Center for Cooperatives, in a paper celebrating the 75th anniversary of the Act in 1997, calls it "the Magna Carta" of agricultural cooperatives, without which "a wide range of cooperative activities" would be prohibited outright.

The grocers contend that the groups being sued are not cooperatives within the meaning of the Act, and, further, that some of the price-fixing activities in which they are claimed to be engaged are not protected. UPGA, they allege, is nothing more nor less than "a scheme to manage and restrict the supply of potatoes."

Mark Patterson, professor of law at Fordham University and an expert on anti-trust, tells ABC News that even if the plaintiffs meet the Act's definition of a coop, it's not clear that limiting production is one of the activities permitted. "The statute," says he, "does not list that as allowed. You're allowed to market goods in such a way as to try to get a higher price," but the law is "just not clear" that a coop can restrict the quantity of goods to do that.

Moreover, he says, one coop cannot legally collude with another. So, while one coop's restricting output would be questionable, he says, an agreement between coops to do so would be "worse."

On the last point, Mark Grady concurs. Grady, a professor of law and expert on anti-trust at UCLA, says price-fixing within a coop is okay—privileged under the Act. "But there is no privilege between coops."

View Comments (749)

Recommended for You

  • ‘DWTS’ Season 23: Former Texas Gov. Rick Perry Booted from Ballroom in Week 3

    The voters have spoken. Former Texas Gov. Rick Perry was sent packing from “Dancing With the Stars” tonight after just three weeks of competition.During his time on the show, the 66-year-old former longtime governor who twice unsuccessfully sought the Republican party’s nomination for president…

    Good Morning America
  • Brad Pitt Is Skipping His Movie Premiere Because of His 'Family Situation'

    Brad Pitt will not be walking the red carpet tomorrow, he told ABC News.The actor, who narrates Terrence Malick's documentary, "Voyage of Time," is skipping the film's premiere as a result of recent events that have taken place in his personal life.Last week, news broke that Pitt's relationship…

    Good Morning America
  • Rescued Boater Said Boat 'Dropped Out From Under His Feet,' Mom Disappeared

    The 22-year-old boater who was rescued after spending eight days at sea in a life raft told the Coast Guard that he and his mother were fishing when there was a "funny noise" in the engine compartment, according to audio from a radio call he made from the Chinese freighter that rescued him. Today,…

    Good Morning America
  • Wells Fargo CEO Forgoes $41M Compensation Amid Accounts Scandal

    Two days before Wells Fargo CEO John Stumpf was set to testify at a House hearing over an accounts scandal that has gripped the company, the bank's independent directors have announced that he will forgo $41 million worth of promised compensation as well as his usual salary as it launches an…

    Good Morning America
  • Charlotte Police Find Suspicious Package at Headquarters

    A suspicious package was found at the headquarters of the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department Tuesday -- days after a black man was killed by police, sparking violent protests.Police said an employee in the mail room noticed the package and bomb-sniffing dogs were brought in to…

    Good Morning America
  • Gigi Hadid Urges Women in Unsafe Situations to 'Fight Back'

    Gigi Hadid has addressed criticism that she was wrong to fight back against a former TV reporter who manhandled her last week. In an interview with Lena Dunham for her newsletter, Lenny Letter, Hadid said that her reaction was automatic, and that she doesn't regret attempting to elbow Vitalii…

    Good Morning America
  • Man Arrested in Connection With Bronx Blast That Killed Firefighter, Injured More Than a Dozen Others

    Julio Salcedo, 32, was arrested this afternoon in Cliffside Park, New Jersey, the law enforcement source said. Fire officials and police originally responded to the single-family house in the Bronx this morning after receiving a report of a gas odor, Fire Commissioner Dan Nigro said at a news…

    Good Morning America
  • SpaceX Unveils Plan for Manned Mars Mission

    Humans could set foot on Mars within the next 10 years -- at least if SpaceX CEO Elon Musk has his way. Building such a complex system will cost a lot of money -- so much that Musk hasn’t yet named a dollar figure.

    Good Morning America
  • How Hillary Clinton Got Under Donald Trump's Skin During the Debate

    One of the big questions Monday night was how Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump would try to goad each other into losing their cool during their first face-off. Aaron Kall, the director of debate at the University of Michigan, said he thought Clinton’s attack on Trump's tax returns "was the most…

    Good Morning America
  • Hillary Clinton Pans Donald Trump's 1st Debate Performance: 'He Made It Very Clear That He Didn't Prepare'

    Hillary Clinton came out swinging against Donald Trump today after the first presidential debate of the general-election season, criticizing his post-performance gripes, questioning his wealth and suggesting a "strong probability" the GOP nominee has not paid federal income taxes in years. "He…

    Good Morning America
  • Men Charged After Protesting Ryan Lochte on 'Dancing With the Stars'

    The Los Angeles City Attorney's Office filed criminal complaints on Monday against Sam Sotoodeh and Barzeen Soroudi, who rushed the stage of the ABC show earlier this month to protest Lochte's casting. During the season premiere of "Dancing With the Stars," Sotoodeh and Soroudi interrupted the…

    Good Morning America
  • This Mom Threw Out Her Kids' Toys and Got Her Life Back

    Allie Casazza was drowning. In toys.“I had this huge room in my house, dedicated to toys,” she told ABC News. “Bins overflowing with stuff. A $150 light-up unicorn no one played with. The playroom was the bane of my existence.”She describes a scene familiar to many moms. “I’d send the kids into the…

    Good Morning America
  • Elderly Couple Reunited After Forced to Live in Separate Nursing Homes for Months

    The reunion, which was filled with "tears of joy," came after Wolfram Gottschalk, 83, and Anita Gottschalk, 81, were photographed crying in late August during a visitation a few months after they were first separated, according to their granddaughter, Ashley Bartyik. "This is the saddest photo I…

    Good Morning America
  • Young Girl's Emotional Council Speech Laments 'Shame' of Fatal Charlotte Shooting

    Peaceful protesters crowded Charlotte's first city council meeting since the cop shooting of Keith Lamont Scott, with over 50 people speaking out against police violence. Zianna Oliphant, her hair done up in braids and tears streaking her face, brought into focus the stress police shootings place…

    Good Morning America
  • Dolphin Collides With Teen Surfer Riding a Wave in Australia

    A teen surfer off of the coast of Western Australia was surprised when a dolphin jumped straight into the wave he was riding. "I was in a bit of pain when the dolphin landed on me, I think I pulled my back out a bit. Gradisen's surfboard still has a hole from where the dolphin dove straight into…

    Good Morning America
  • 8-Year-Old Writes Hilarious Guide to Third Grade

    One 8-year-old has penned a hilarious, and brutally honest, how-to-guide for surviving third grade. Christopher Bannon, of Staten Island, New York, wrote the guide, simply titled “How to Survive 3rd Grade," for a school assignment, according to his mom, Melissa Barvels. Christopher and his…

    Good Morning America
  • Jennifer Aniston's Husband Justin Theroux Sounds Off on Brad Pitt's Divorce

    After news broke last week that Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie were splitting, the Jennifer Aniston memes began. Fans took to social media to post jokes involving Pitt's first ex-wife. Aniston and Pitt were married from 2000 to 2005.

    Good Morning America