Vets Angry Over Film About Fraudster Posing as Fallen Soldier

Good Morning America
Vets Angry Over Film About Fraudster Posing as Fallen Soldier

View photo

Vets Angry Over Film About Fraudster Posing as Fallen Soldier (ABC News)

Sgt. 1st Class John H. Robertson was aboard a Vietnamese Air Force H-34 helicopter on a special operations mission over Laos when it was shot down by enemy ground fire and exploded on May 20, 1968. U.S. servicemen who witnessed the crash say there were no survivors, and his body was never recovered.

In 1976, a military review board changed Robertson's status from "missing in action" to officially deceased; his wife, who later remarried, and two young daughters moved on.

A new documentary, "Unclaimed," suggests that Robertson is still alive at 77, living in the jungle. But the U.S. government has said emphatically that the man -- a French-born, Vietnam citizen Dang Tan Ngoc -- is a well-investigated scammer.

The film premiered this week at Toronto's Hot Docs film festival, and will have its first American screening May 12 at the GI Film Festival in Washington, D.C.

Canadian director Michael Jorgensen's controversial documentary suggests the former Green Beret has for the past 44 years lived in poverty and is now married to a Vietnamese woman with four children. He speaks no English, according to the film, but in a reunion with his sister in Canada depicted in the documentary, she says he is for real.

The film is in English, but the director uses the services of a Vietnamese translator who immigrated to Canada when Saigon fell to the Communist government in the 1970s.

Jorgensen told that what drew him to the story was his "highest regard" for those who serve in the military, who are "willing to sacrifice themselves for an ideal or just your brother. ...guys who go shoulder to shoulder with you on the battlefield."

The filmmaker asks why the American government left Robertson -- and perhaps others -- behind.

The military has investigated the case three times over the last decade, according to the Defense POW/Missing Personnel Office. "All claims and alleged live sighting reports related to Robertson have been investigated, and found to be false," they said in a statement.

Government reports obtained by show, among other details, that the man's fingerprints did not match those of the fallen soldier.

The film has enraged some veterans' groups who say that the man purporting to be Robertson is a fraud and giving the film a showcase at the GI Film Festival is an insult to those who served honorably in the Vietnam War.

"... you chose to tarnish the legacy of valor of American heroes to line your pockets with thirty pieces of silver or further your agenda," wrote Don Bendell, an author and former Green Beret who served in the special forces in Vietnam, wrote to the president of the GI Festival. "You apparently do not have the balls or principle to see how you are hurting the families of veterans on this by providing a forum for a complete scam.

"You have helped con artists to give false hope to a poor unfortunate sister and survivors of an honorable hero who are clutching at any possible straw of hope that their hero might still be alive."

Bendell, 66, who has been active in the P.O.W. Network and its Fake Warriors Project, which uncover cases of "stolen valor," said that in 2006 the Robertson imposter "admitted to the government that he was a con artist and part of a fake con game.

"We know this guy is a fake," he told "I don't know if it's fame or fortune or what it is. Some people want their 15 minutes."

Bendell said the notion that Robertson could not speak English is "stupid," especially because of his training in special operations. "To make it you have to have an above average IQ and high language aptitude," he said. "The guy was no dummy...How can a person forget their native language?"

According to the government report, the crash site had not yet been excavated to look for bodies or DNA. But Bendell said, "Green Berets don't leave guys behind. There was no way others would have left him on the ground if he had been wounded."

Brandon L. Millett, co-founder and president of the GI Film Festival, has told that he is aware of the controversy surrounding the film. He said the Washington-D.C.-based festival, which in the past has honored actors like Gary Sinese, will screen "Unclaimed," despite its critics.

"The festival ... will issue a statement prior to the screening to let the audience know about the objections to the film and its content -- because one of the film festival's jobs is to screen interesting stories that stimulate public debate and foster conversation," he said in a statement.

John Hartley Robertson was born in Birmingham, Ala., in 1936, according to the film. He dropped out of school to join the Army and was later chosen to be part of the elite Special Operations Group in Vietnam, MACV-SOG. He was on a war mission when the helicopter crashed in Laos.

"Unclaimed" follows the journey of Tom Faunce, a Michigan man who served two years in Vietnam and made a pledge to uphold his military oath, "leave no man behind." He returns to Vietnam four decades later and discovers a mysterious man who claims to be Robertson.

Faunce works to prove the lost soldier's identity, reuniting him with his family, sister Jean, brother-in-law Henry Holley and their two daughters, Gail and Judy. The filmmakers say the documentary provides a public forum to seek answers from the government in the handling of the case and to have conclusive DNA testing.

Jorgensen, who shot the film last year in Vietnam, Canada and the U.S, told that the government has never made contact with Jean Robertson-Holley or her family. Just after the film was made, the elder Holleys were critically injured in a car accident and are now in a long-term care facility.

He wonders why the government never called the family when they were interrogating Dang Tan Ngoc, allegedly as far back as 1991 or even 1982. The last such inquiry was in 2009 when the fingerprints were analyzed, according to government reports.

"That's standard operating procedure," he said. "It's simple enough. If someone is perpetrating a hoax or is a fraudster, do your due diligence and warn people, contact the family."

Jorgensen said he spoke to a "representative" of Robertson's American wife, who had since remarried. "They just don't want to be involved," he said. "I was very respectful of that."

"I am absolutely convinced, 100 percent, that the family is convinced it is him," he said of Robertson's sister and brother-in-law. "I never set out to prove his identity. The film was about one Vietnam veteran's journey to help a guy find this man's family. ... Tom's story amazing story of what it means to be human."

As for the director of the GI Film Festival, he says "Unclaimed" is an important film that needs to be screened.

"Whether fact or fiction, "Unclaimed" is a fascinating story about a Vietnam veteran ... who dedicates himself to bringing home someone he believes to be an American GI left behind," said the film festival's Millett.

"Even if he is chasing a myth, we feel his story is compelling and worth telling, as long as it is accompanied by a disclosure to viewers about the controversy surrounding it."

View Comments (1353)

Recommended for You

  • Wimbledon 2015: Bob Woodruff Takes Us Inside the Hallowed Tennis Championship

    Wimbledon is the oldest tennis tournament in the world, and arguably the most anticipated of the four Grand Slam events every year. Wimbledon is the only Grand Slam event still played on grass, and boasts 41 courts, including 19 championships grass courts. Inside the gates, spectators can watch…

    Good Morning America29 mins ago
  • Georgia Dentist Office Defends ‘Papoose' Restraint After Parent Complaint

    A Georgia dentistry practice that’s under fire for using a restraint device on a child is defending its use of the so-called papoose board, saying every parent signs a consent form and is allowed to stay with the child during a procedure. “[The] guideline is, if the child is moving a lot or…

    Good Morning America51 mins ago
  • Mystery Solved: Woman With Amnesia and Battling Cancer Has Been Identified

    The woman, who called herself "Sam" since she was found by firefighters in Carlsbad, California, in February, has learned that she is Ashley Manetta, a 53-year-old woman who was born in Pennsylvania and later lived in Arizona and California, according to a Facebook page that has been leading…

    Good Morning America
  • Whole Foods Founder John Mackey, CEO Walter Robb Apologize for Overcharging

    The CEOs of Whole Foods are apologizing for overcharging customers and offering free food to people in return. Investigators found Whole Foods locations in New York City "routinely overstated" the weight of pre-packaged contents and overcharged customers, according to an announcement by the city's…

    Good Morning America
  • GoFundMe Page Asked for Money to Cover Dylann Roof's Sister’s Wedding After Charleston Shooting

    A GoFundMe page administered by someone claiming to be Amber Roof asked for donations to fund a "dream honeymoon" and pay off her wedding that was canceled after Dylann Roof allegedly killed nine people at a historic black church in Charleston, South Carolina, last month. Dylann Roof has a sister…

    Good Morning America
  • Miniature Horse Tied for World's Tiniest Poised for Big Things

    Even for a miniature horse, Itty Bitty Hope is pretty small. "She'll be able to navigate around hospitals and nursing homes and medical equipment more easily," said her owner Linda Wood, who runs the Mini Hooves of Love Miniature Therapy Horses non-profit with her husband Jim Wood. The Woods came…

    Good Morning America
  • Why America Ferrera Is Saying 'Thank You!' to Donald Trump

    Actress and activist America Ferrera joined the growing ranks of Donald Trump opponents today, arguing in an online missive that the real estate mogul’s recent comments about Latinos are backfiring. “I heard what you said about the kind of people you think Latino immigrants are -- people with…

    Good Morning America
  • 5 Storylines the 'Melrose Place' TV Movie Should Address

    "Melrose Place" aired its final episode in 1999, but it's coming back! In 1992, when "Melrose Place" premiered, it was considered groundbreaking to have an openly gay character, let alone one who, in 1994, had a boyfriend who tested positive for HIV. Some critics complained, however, that Matt…

    Good Morning America
  • New Horizons Sends Back Images of Mystery Dark Spots on Pluto

    Several mysterious dark spots on the surface of Pluto have caught the attention of NASA researchers as the New Horizons probe makes its final approach to the dwarf planet. Several spots are evenly spaced along Pluto's equator, with each having a diameter of about 300 miles, according to NASA. …

    Good Morning America
  • A Look at the Hazardous Chemical That Forced Thousands to Evacuate After Train Caught on Fire

    The chemical that was being transported on the train that caught fire in Tennessee is called vinyl cyandide, and it has vapors that explode when exposed to fire, authorities said today. First responders ordered an evacuation of residences and businesses in a two-mile radius around where the fire…

    Good Morning America
  • Expert Advice on How to Avoid the Top 3 Grilling Gaffes

    Mike Peters, president of the Kansas City Barbeque Society and award-winning barbecue champion, gives his best advice for battling the top three grilling gaffes.

    Good Morning America
  • Ben Affleck Talks 'Sexy Scene,' Reveals Secrets From 'Batman v Superman'

    In advance of Comic-Con, Entertainment Weekly spoke to "Batman v Superman" stars Ben Affleck and Henry Cavill -- and some of the quotes that go along with the slideshow are very telling almost as much as the photos themselves. Bruce Wayne, played by Affleck, might have some kind of "sexy scene,"…

    Good Morning America
  • Here's the Zebra That 'Sings' for Snacks

    A dad on vacation with his family got a zebra to “sing” for its snacks.The Fowler family was visiting the Natural Bridge Caverns Wildlife Ranch in San Antonio, Texas, when it go up close with a zebra.As the family sat in their car, the zebra came close to the opened car window, hoping for…

    Good Morning America
  • Homeless Florida Man's Beautiful Piano Performance Might Earn Him a Job

    One passerby, Aurore Henry, took notice of the bearded mystery man as he sat at the piano effortlessly playing a beautiful rendition of Styx’s “Come Sail Away.” She was so impressed with his talents that she uploaded the video of his sidewalk serenade to her Facebook page where it now has a…

    Good Morning America
  • Washington Navy Yard Response Highlights Preparedness to Potential Terror Attacks

    The response to a suspected active shooter at the Washington Navy Yard this morning was swift and massive. When the 911 call came in at 7:29 a.m. ET that gunshots had been heard at the Navy Yard, dozens of officers from Naval Security, D.C. Metropolitan Police, U.S. Capitol Police, Park Police,…

    Good Morning America
  • USPS Unveils New Elvis Stamp Artwork

    Just like his previous postage stamp from 1993, a new stamp featuring Elvis Presley shows the King of Rock and Roll in his youthful glory.The United States Postal Service released the artwork today for the upcoming Presley stamp that will be issued on Aug. 12 as part of the agency's Music Icons…

    Good Morning America
  • Stephen Colbert Interviews Eminem on a Michigan Cable Access Show

    While not in his "Colbert Report" persona, Colbert was certainly in character, deadpanning through the 41-plus minute program as any local host would, on location in the local access channel's studio, which Colbert said was the perfect channel "to binge watch 2014 city council meetings.

    Good Morning America